University labour dispute bill seeks mediation-arbitration

Summary#

Bill 70, the York University Labour Disputes Resolution Act, 2018, would create a special Act to address labour disputes between York University and CUPE Local 3903. It would apply to three specified bargaining units if no new agreement had been signed before the bill received Royal Assent; its stated goal is to end the disruption and reach new agreements through mediation-arbitration.

  • York would have to make reasonable efforts to operate, and the union and employees would have to end any strike; York would have to end any lock-out.
  • Until new agreements are in place, strikes and lock-outs would be prohibited, subject to an exception for employees not reporting to work for health reasons or by mutual agreement with York.
  • The parties would have to jointly appoint a mediator-arbitrator. If they did not notify the Minister of Labour of an appointment, the Minister would appoint one.
  • The mediator-arbitrator would have exclusive authority to decide matters considered necessary for the agreements. Their award would be final and binding.
  • Existing employment terms would continue until new agreements took effect, unless the parties agreed otherwise. An award could change terms retroactively to dates after August 31, 2017.
  • The Act would apply to Unit 1 (part-time graduate students teaching, demonstrating, tutoring or marking); Unit 2 (specified teaching workers, with listed exclusions); and Unit 3 (specified full-time graduate students doing administrative, clerical or research work in connection with financial assistance, with listed exclusions).

What it means for you#

  • York, CUPE Local 3903 and covered employees: If the bill became law and applied to a unit, both sides would have to use the mediation-arbitration process unless they reached an agreement first. Employees could not strike and York could not lock them out while the prohibitions applied. The regular rules in the Labour Relations Act, 1995 would govern strike and lock-out rights again after a new agreement took effect.
  • Employees: The mediator-arbitrator would set the process but must let both sides present evidence and submissions. The mediator-arbitrator must consider listed factors, including York’s ability to pay, possible service reductions, Ontario and Greater Toronto Area economic conditions, and comparisons with similar employees.
  • Students and families: The bill does not directly change student rights, fees, course requirements or academic rules. Its preamble says restoring classes and normal university operations is a goal; it does not guarantee a particular academic outcome.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill does not set a tax, create a benefit or establish a new public service. It would create a special dispute-resolution process that takes priority over conflicting parts of the Labour Relations Act, 1995.

Money#

No publicly available information on total public or university costs.

  • York and CUPE would each pay half of the mediator-arbitrator’s fees and expenses.
  • The bill sets fines for breaches of its strike, lock-out and operating duties: up to $2,000 for an individual and up to $25,000 for another person or a trade union. Each day of a breach would count as a separate offence.
  • The bill does not state a government spending amount or estimate staffing costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s application depends on whether an agreement was signed before Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether it became law or whether that condition was met.
  • The mediator-arbitrator’s authority covers matters they consider necessary to conclude an agreement. The bill does not give a narrower list of what may be decided.
  • The parties may extend the 90-day award deadline by written agreement; the bill does not set a final deadline if they do.
  • The Act would be repealed on a date set by proclamation, but the bill does not set that date.
  • The supplied material does not describe how the process would affect particular students’ courses, placements or graduation plans.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address a deadlock that its preamble describes as disrupting students’ education and university operations.
  • A mediator-arbitrator could help the parties reach agreement; if they could not, the process would still produce a binding agreement.
  • The bill preserves the parties’ ability to keep negotiating and settle matters themselves before an award.
  • It sets factors for the award, including York’s ability to pay and the potential effect on services.

Case against#

  • The bill would require an end to a strike or lock-out and bar either during the process, limiting the parties’ ability to use those actions in bargaining.
  • If the parties could not agree, a mediator-arbitrator would decide the terms, and the award would bind both sides and employees.
  • The Minister could appoint the mediator-arbitrator if the parties did not make an appointment. The bill says that appointment cannot be challenged or stopped through an application.
  • The bill requires the parties to share the mediator-arbitrator’s fees but does not provide a cost estimate or specify a limit.