Imposed School Labour Pact Ends Strikes

Summary#

Bill 28, the Keeping Students in Class Act, 2022, created a new Ontario law; it did not amend a single existing Act. It imposed collective agreements between school boards and CUPE for school-board employees represented by CUPE, and overrode parts of other labour laws where they conflicted. Its stated goal was to prevent further school disruptions and support students’ learning.

  • The imposed agreements took effect when the Act received Royal Assent and ran to August 31, 2026. They included new central terms and most local terms from agreements that expired on August 31, 2022, subject to changes in the Act and central terms.
  • Any strike or lock-out then in progress had to end. School boards had to make reasonable efforts to resume interrupted operations; affected employees had to return to work, with exceptions for health reasons or mutual agreement.
  • Strikes and lock-outs were prohibited during the imposed agreements’ term. Breaches could bring fines of up to $4,000 for an individual or $500,000 for another person or organization; each day counted as a separate offence.
  • The agreements set wage increases, benefit funding, sick-leave rules and other terms. They also protected staffing levels subject to listed exceptions, and provided funding for specified school supports and apprenticeship training.
  • The Act said it operated notwithstanding Charter sections 2, 7 and 15, and applied despite Ontario’s Human Rights Code. It also restricted certain proceedings and remedies against the Crown.

What it means for you#

  • Students and families: The law required a return to school operations after any strike or lock-out in progress. Keeping classes running and supporting student learning were stated goals, not guaranteed results.
  • CUPE-represented school-board employees: The imposed agreement set pay, benefits, leave and other workplace terms. For positions below the specified pay thresholds, wages rose by 2.5% on each of four dates; for positions at or above the thresholds, they rose by 1.5% on each date. The agreement also provided a one-time payment based on earnings in the 67 days before November 7, 2022.
  • Employees and unions: Employees could not strike during the agreement’s term, and unions and their officials could not call for or encourage a strike. Certain local terms limiting an employer’s ability to run an employee-attendance support program were void to that extent.
  • School boards: Boards had to follow the imposed terms, make reasonable efforts to restart interrupted operations, and meet the agreement’s funding and staffing obligations. Staffing reductions were allowed in specified cases, including declining enrolment, some funding cuts, and school closures or consolidations.
  • Taxpayers: The agreement included public funding commitments, but the supplied materials do not give a total cost estimate.
  • The imposed agreements ended on August 31, 2026. The materials do not say what agreements or strike rules apply after that date.

Money#

The agreement specifies several funding and pay commitments, but the supplied materials give no total cost estimate.

  • It lists annual “Supports for Students” funding of about $59.8 million in 2022–23, rising to $63.3 million in 2025–26. The Crown’s funding commitment was conditional on approval where required.
  • It provides a one-time $4.5 million fund for skilled-trades apprenticeships, with unspent funds to return to the Crown.
  • It lists $651,835 for community use of schools and says the Crown will maintain that investment during the agreement, subject to approval where required.
  • School-board benefit contributions were set per full-time-equivalent employee, starting at $5,712 and rising to $6,120.48 by August 31, 2026. The agreement also set wage increases and one-time payments, but no total wage cost.
  • The materials do not say how much of these listed amounts was ultimately spent or paid.

What is unclear#

  • The materials do not establish what agreements or strike rules replaced the imposed agreements after August 31, 2026.
  • They do not give a total estimate for wage increases, benefit contributions, or the overall public cost.
  • The school-support and community-use funding commitments were conditional on approval where required; the materials do not say whether all required approvals were given.
  • The Act limits some legal challenges, but the supplied materials do not explain how those limits would apply in every possible case.
  • The Act required reasonable efforts to resume operations but did not set a deadline or detailed steps for doing so.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to prevent another interruption to school for students after pandemic-related disruptions. A fixed agreement and a ban on strikes and lock-outs could provide continuity during the agreement’s term.
  • The imposed terms set pay and benefits for a defined period and included funds for school staffing supports and apprenticeships.
  • The staffing terms allowed some reductions while setting limits tied to enrolment, funding reductions, and school closures or consolidations.

Case against#

  • The law imposed collective agreements rather than leaving their terms to the parties’ bargaining process. A possible concern is that this restricted employees’ and employers’ ability to resolve disputes through normal bargaining.
  • The strike and lock-out bans were backed by large fines, including separate offences for each day of a breach.
  • The Act limited challenges under specified Charter rights and the Human Rights Code, restricted some tribunals from considering those issues, and barred many claims for compensation against the Crown. That could limit access to remedies.
  • The funding and wage commitments could involve substantial public costs, but the supplied materials do not provide an overall estimate.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2022110301

    Passed111 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 28, An Act to resolve labour disputes involving school board employees represented by the Canadian Union of Public Employees.

    FOR · 78AGAINST · 33

    78For

    • PC78

    33Against

    • NDP25
    • Liberal7
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2022110302

    Passed108 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 28

    FOR · 76AGAINST · 32

    76For

    • PC76

    32Against

    • NDP25
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2022110303

    Passed108 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 28

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 34

    74For

    • PC74

    34Against

    • NDP26
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  4. Division No. 2022103103

    Passed103 members voted

    On motion by Hon. Stephen Lecce, Bill 28, An Act to resolve labour disputes involving school board employees represented by the Canadian Union of Public Employees, was introduced and read…

    FOR · 71AGAINST · 32

    71For

    • PC71

    32Against

    • NDP25
    • Liberal6
    • Green1