Hospice Care Framework Bill

Summary#

Bill 182, the Compassionate Care Act, 2017, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to support improved access to hospice palliative care by requiring the Minister of Health and Long-Term Care to develop a provincial framework.

  • The Minister must develop a framework covering care provided through hospitals, home care, long-term care homes and hospices.
  • The framework must define hospice palliative care; identify training and education needs for health care providers and other caregivers; identify measures to support providers and more consistent access; promote research and data collection; and consider existing frameworks, strategies and best practices.
  • The Minister must consult hospice palliative care providers, affected ministries and the federal government, as well as any other people or organizations the Minister considers appropriate. Consultations must start within six months after the law comes into force.
  • The Minister must table the framework within one year after the law comes into force and publish it online within 10 days. Within five years after that report is tabled, the Minister must prepare a report on the state of hospice palliative care in Ontario, table it within a specified sitting-day window and publish it online within 10 days.

What it means for you#

  • Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care: The Minister would have to develop the framework, consult, and prepare and publish the two reports by the stated deadlines.
  • Hospice palliative care providers, other caregivers and health care providers: Their needs must be addressed in the framework. Providers must be consulted, but the bill does not require the Minister to adopt their recommendations.
  • People seeking hospice palliative care and their families: The bill would require planning and reporting, but would not itself create a right to care, guarantee access, or set out a new care service.
  • General public: The framework and the later report would have to be published on a Government of Ontario website.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires ministerial work, consultations, reports and online publication, but gives no staffing or spending amount.
  • It does not set a fee, benefit, tax, fine or funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • “Hospice palliative care” is not defined in the bill; defining it is one task the framework must address.
  • The bill does not specify what measures the framework must recommend, or how those measures would be funded or put into effect.
  • The Minister decides which additional people or organizations to consult. The bill does not set out how consultation will work or how views will affect the framework.
  • The bill does not set measures for assessing access or explain what data will be collected.
  • Whether Bill 182 became law, or what hospice palliative care rules and services currently exist in Ontario: No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A province-wide framework could give the government a way to identify access gaps across hospitals, home care, long-term care homes and hospices.
  • The required focus on training, provider support, research and data could help inform future planning.
  • Required consultation and public reports could make the planning process and the reported state of care visible.

Case against#

  • The bill requires a framework and reports, but does not require specific services, funding or access improvements. Better access is a goal, not a guaranteed result.
  • The bill leaves the framework’s practical measures and implementation to be worked out later.
  • The bill does not require the Minister to consult every affected person or organization, or explain how consultation views will be considered.