Summary#
Bill 114, the Nancy Rose Act (Paediatric Hospice Palliative Care Strategy), 2019, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would require the Minister of Health and Long-Term Care to develop and put in place a provincial strategy. The stated goal is more equal access to high-quality paediatric hospice palliative care across Ontario.
- The strategy must include targeted supports for families of children receiving hospice palliative care, including mental health supports.
- The Minister must publish a report setting out the strategy by the first anniversary of the Act receiving Royal Assent. The Minister must keep assessing the strategy and change it as needed, publishing a report when it is amended.
- The bill would establish an advisory committee appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. It would have 5 to 9 members, with a majority of regulated health professionals with relevant expertise and the remaining members family members of children receiving or having received hospice palliative care.
- Committee membership must include representation from London, Hamilton, Toronto, Kingston and Ottawa, plus any other areas set by regulation. Members would serve two-year terms and could be reappointed.
- The committee must advise the Minister, review a 2011 paediatric palliative care work group report and adopt recommendations from it as the committee considers appropriate. It must report its recommendations to the Minister each year; the Minister must publish and table those reports.
What it means for you#
- Families of children receiving paediatric hospice palliative care: The strategy must include targeted family supports, including mental health supports. The bill does not itself provide those services or give families a direct right to receive them.
- Health professionals and family members appointed to the committee: They would advise the Minister. The bill sets membership requirements but does not say how members are selected beyond appointment by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
- Minister and Ontario government: The Minister must develop and implement the strategy, publish reports, assess its effectiveness and amend it as needed. The Minister may make regulations about committee procedures, members’ duties and additional geographic representation.
- Other patients and the public: The bill does not directly change eligibility for care, require a particular service in a particular location, or set a standard for the care providers must deliver.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.
- The bill requires the Minister to develop and implement a strategy and establish reporting; it does not state a budget or estimate the staffing or other resources required.
- It does not set fees, fines, benefits or a funding amount for family supports or care services.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define paediatric hospice palliative care, “equity of access” or “high quality.”
- It does not specify which supports families must receive, who would provide them, how families would access them, or how services would be funded.
- It does not set measures for assessing the strategy’s effectiveness or explain what the Minister must do if access remains unequal.
- It does not set committee procedures, explain how recommendations would be considered, or say how the committee’s work would be resourced.
- The bill does not state when the strategy itself must be implemented beyond requiring a report by the first anniversary of Royal Assent.
Case for#
- A provincial strategy could give the Minister a way to address access and quality across Ontario, rather than treating them only as local issues.
- Requiring family supports, including mental health supports, recognizes that the strategy is meant to address families’ needs as well as children’s care.
- The committee would include both relevant health professionals and family members, bringing professional expertise and family experience into advice to the Minister.
- Annual public reports and ongoing assessment could make recommendations and changes visible.
Case against#
- The bill sets a goal of more equal access but does not require a specific level of care, service or funding. The goal may therefore be difficult to measure or enforce.
- Family supports are required as part of the strategy, but the bill does not guarantee that a family will receive a particular support.
- The Minister has broad discretion over the strategy’s content and changes; the bill does not require the Minister to follow the committee’s recommendations.
- The bill creates duties and a committee without estimating the resources needed, so the cost and practical capacity to carry them out are unknown.