Provincial paediatric hospice strategy proposed

Summary#

Bill 31 would create the Nancy Rose Act (Paediatric Hospice Palliative Care Strategy), 2021; it does not amend another Act. It would require Ontario’s Minister of Health to develop and implement a provincial strategy. The stated goal is more equitable access to high-quality paediatric hospice palliative care across Ontario.

  • The strategy must include targeted supports for families of children receiving hospice palliative care, including mental health supports.
  • Within one year after Royal Assent, the Minister must publish a report setting out the strategy. The Minister must keep assessing its effectiveness and make changes as necessary; reports setting out changes must also be published.
  • The bill would establish an advisory committee of 5 to 9 members appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. Most must be regulated health professionals with particular expertise in paediatric hospice palliative care; the rest must be family members of children receiving or previously receiving that care.
  • The committee must advise the Minister, review recommendations from a 2011 work-group report and adopt those it considers appropriate, with or without changes. It must prepare an annual report by May 4; the Minister must publish it and table it in the Legislative Assembly.
  • Committee membership must include representation from London, Hamilton, Toronto, Kingston and Ottawa. Regulations may add other regions and set committee procedures and members’ duties.

What it means for you#

  • Families of children receiving hospice palliative care: The strategy must include targeted family supports, including mental health supports. The bill does not guarantee a particular service, amount of support or individual entitlement.
  • Health professionals and family members on the committee: Members would advise the Minister, but the bill does not require the Minister to accept their recommendations.
  • People across Ontario: The strategy’s stated goal is equitable access, but the bill does not set service levels or require that a particular service be available in every area.
  • Public: Strategy reports and committee annual reports must be published. The bill does not set a deadline for the committee’s first report beyond its annual May 4 deadline.
  • Current services: The bill does not itself set out changes to existing care services or explain how the strategy would interact with them.

Money#

No publicly available information gives a cost estimate.

  • The Minister would have to develop and implement the strategy, assess it over time, and publish reports; the committee would also have to prepare annual reports. The bill does not specify staffing, funding or costs for these duties.
  • The bill does not create a stated appropriation, tax, fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “equity of access,” “high quality” or “targeted supports.”
  • It does not specify which services the strategy must cover, how families would access supports, or what service levels would apply.
  • It does not set a budget, identify who would deliver or pay for supports, or explain how existing programs would fit with the strategy.
  • The bill does not say how the Minister must respond to committee recommendations.
  • The committee must include representation from five named cities, but the bill does not specify how other parts of Ontario would be represented unless regulations add regions.
  • The text says the Act would start on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not say whether it has received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A provincial strategy could set a common direction for improving access and care quality across Ontario.
  • Requiring targeted family supports, including mental health supports, puts family needs within the strategy’s scope.
  • Having health professionals and family members advise the Minister brings both care expertise and family experience into the process.
  • Ongoing assessment and public reports could make the strategy’s development and changes more visible.

Case against#

  • The bill requires a strategy but does not set minimum services, access standards or an individual right to care. The goal may therefore remain unmet without further decisions and resources.
  • It does not specify funding, delivery arrangements or how families would obtain the supports the strategy develops.
  • The committee advises the Minister, but the bill does not require the Minister to act on its recommendations.
  • The Minister may make regulations about committee procedures and members’ duties, but the bill does not set those details itself.