Hospice Care Framework Would Guide Access

Summary#

Bill 33, the Compassionate Care Act, 2018, would create a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would require the Minister of Health and Long-Term Care to develop and report on a provincial framework intended to support improved access to hospice palliative care.

  • The framework must cover care provided through hospitals, home care, long-term care homes and hospices. It must define hospice palliative care; identify training and education needs for health care providers and other caregivers; identify measures to support care providers; promote research and data collection; identify ways to support consistent access across Ontario; and consider existing frameworks, strategies and best practices.
  • The Minister must develop the framework in consultation with hospice palliative care providers, affected ministries, the federal government and others the Minister considers appropriate. Consultations must start within six months after the law takes effect.
  • The Minister must table a report setting out the framework within one year after the law takes effect and publish it online within 10 days.
  • Within five years after that report is tabled, the Minister must prepare a report on the state of hospice palliative care in Ontario, table it within a set sitting-day window, and publish it online within 10 days.

What it means for you#

  • People who need hospice palliative care and their families: The bill would require planning and reporting aimed at supporting improved access. It would not itself guarantee a service, create an individual right to care, or set eligibility rules.
  • Care providers and caregivers: Providers must be consulted in developing the framework. The framework must identify their training and education needs and measures to support providers. The bill does not require particular training or support to be delivered.
  • Health-care system and public: The Minister must publish both reports. The bill does not set service levels or require hospitals, home care, long-term care homes or hospices to change how they provide care.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Minister to develop the framework and prepare two reports, but gives no estimate for staff time or other costs.
  • It does not specify funding for hospice palliative care services, providers, research or training.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define hospice palliative care itself; it requires the framework to define it.
  • It does not say what actions must follow from the framework or how any proposed measures would be funded.
  • It does not set access standards, targets, measures of progress or a process for people to seek care.
  • It does not specify how the state-of-care report will measure or assess conditions in Ontario.
  • The Minister decides which additional people or entities to consult; the bill does not set a consultation process or require public consultation.

Case for#

  • A provincial framework could help identify differences in access and set out shared priorities across care settings.
  • Requiring attention to training, provider support, research and data collection could help the government identify needs that are not addressed by planning access alone.
  • The consultation and reporting duties create deadlines and make the framework and later report public.

Case against#

  • The bill requires a framework and reports, but does not require new services, funding or changes to care. Its intended improvement in access is not guaranteed.
  • The bill leaves important choices—such as the definition of hospice palliative care and the measures to support consistent access—to the framework, without setting standards in the law.
  • It does not specify targets or how progress will be judged, so the later report may not show whether access improved.