Rowan's Law Concussion Safety

Summary#

Bill 193, Rowan’s Law (Concussion Safety), 2018, is enacted as an Ontario law. It creates that Act and amends the Education Act; its stated goal is concussion safety in amateur sport and schools, not a guaranteed result.

  • Covered sport organizations must create concussion codes of conduct and removal-from-sport and return-to-sport protocols.
  • Those organizations must collect confirmations that athletes and certain adults have reviewed concussion resources and the organization’s code of conduct, as the law and regulations require.
  • The removal protocol must provide for immediate removal of an athlete suspected of having a concussion. The return protocol must set out when an athlete may return.
  • The Minister may require school boards to follow concussion policies and guidelines, and may set concussion requirements for private schools by regulation.
  • The Minister must publish yearly reports on progress implementing some or all recommendations from the Rowan’s Law Advisory Committee report, until a final report is prepared.

What it means for you#

  • Sport organizations: If an organization meets the law’s definition, it must establish the code and protocols and follow the confirmation rules. The definition covers people or entities carrying out prescribed activities connected with amateur competitive sport, plus any other prescribed criteria.
  • Athletes and parents or guardians: An athlete under the age set by regulation cannot be registered in a sports activity without confirming they reviewed the government-approved concussion resources and the organization’s code. A parent or guardian must also confirm for an athlete under 18, unless another age is set by regulation. Further confirmation may be required in other prescribed circumstances.
  • Coaches and other prescribed roles: A sport organization cannot allow someone to coach, or serve in another prescribed position, unless they confirm they reviewed the resources and code at the times and in the way set by regulation.
  • Athletes suspected of having a concussion: The organization’s removal protocol must provide for immediate removal from training, practice or competition. The return protocol applies even if the concussion happened outside activities connected with that organization.
  • School boards and private schools: The Minister may require boards to follow concussion policies and guidelines. The Minister may also make regulations requiring private schools to meet concussion requirements. These are powers, not automatic requirements for every school.
  • General public: The government must make concussion awareness resources public. The last Wednesday in September is Rowan’s Law Day, though the Minister may choose another day for a particular year.

Money#

No publicly available information on the law’s public cost.

  • The law requires sport organizations to develop and make available codes and protocols, which may involve costs; no estimate is provided.
  • The government must make resources available, and the Minister must prepare and publish progress reports. No staffing or cost figures are given.
  • The law does not set a tax, fee, fine or benefit in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The regulations determine which organizations and activities are covered, the relevant ages, confirmation rules, and many protocol details.
  • The law allows regulations to exempt people or organizations and to set different requirements for different types of organizations and sports.
  • The supplied material does not give the proclamation date for the main requirements, so it does not establish when they started.
  • The law does not set out a specific enforcement process or penalty in the supplied text.
  • It does not say how school concussion policies will work in practice; those policies and any private-school requirements may be set later.
  • The law does not define “concussion” in the supplied text.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make concussion information and safety steps part of organized amateur sport.
  • Requiring immediate removal when a concussion is suspected may reduce the chance that an athlete continues participating before the return process allows it.
  • Requiring a return-to-sport protocol, including for concussions that happened outside the organization’s activities, may help organizations apply a consistent process.
  • School policies and public resources extend the law’s reach beyond sport organizations.

Case against#

  • Much of the practical effect depends on future regulations and policies, so the law itself does not settle who is covered or all the required steps.
  • The law gives the government broad power to set different rules or grant exemptions. The supplied text does not explain the criteria for those choices.
  • Sport organizations must create and share materials and protocols, but the law gives no cost estimate or detail about support for them.
  • Annual progress reports track implementation of recommendations, but the law does not require reports on concussion rates or whether the measures improve safety.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2018030605

    Passed91 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 193

    FOR · 91

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    91For

    • Liberal51
    • PC24
    • NDP15
    • Independent1

    0Against

  2. Division No. 2018022101

    Passed89 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 193

    FOR · 89

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    89For

    • Liberal51
    • PC25
    • NDP13

    0Against