Road Safety Act expands enforcement, bike rules

Summary#

Bill 282, the Moving Ontarians More Safely Act, 2021, was enacted. It amends the Highway Traffic Act and the Metrolinx Act, 2006, and creates the Towing and Storage Safety and Enforcement Act, 2021. Its stated goal is to make travel in Ontario safer.

  • It sets different minimum ages for different kinds of power-assisted bicycles: 14 for bicycle-style models and 16 for scooter- or motorcycle-style models. It also changes the legal definition of those bicycles.
  • It increases penalties for racing and stunts: a court must suspend a convicted driver’s licence, and police must request the licence and detain the vehicle when they have reasonable and probable grounds to believe a person raced or performed a stunt. The roadside suspension is 30 days and the impoundment is 14 days.
  • It authorizes automated enforcement for passing a streetcar when it is not permitted. An owner can be convicted for that offence only based on evidence from such a system.
  • It creates a certification and enforcement system for tow operators, tow-truck drivers and vehicle-storage operators. A Director of Towing and Vehicle Storage Standards runs the system; this is an office, not a new independent agency.
  • It requires reporting certain accidents involving an open or opening vehicle door that hits a cyclist, bicycle or moving vehicle. It also allows automated flagger-assistance devices and makes other road-rule changes, including setting an 80 km/h speed limit on specified highways unless another limit applies.
  • Some provisions took effect on Royal Assent; others require a proclamation to start. The towing law’s main provisions also require proclamation.

What it means for you#

  • People who ride power-assisted bicycles, and their parents or guardians: Riders must meet the age limit for the bicycle’s type. Owners or people in control must not let an underage person ride it on a highway. Parents or guardians must not permit a child under 16 to ride one without the required helmet.
  • Drivers and vehicle owners: A person convicted of racing or performing a stunt faces a mandatory court-ordered licence suspension: one to three years for a first conviction, longer for later convictions, and potentially indefinite for a third or later conviction. Police must also impose the 30-day roadside suspension and 14-day vehicle impoundment when the legal grounds are met. The owner bears impoundment costs and risk. The law provides no appeal or right to be heard before those roadside measures, but court proceedings remain possible.
  • People involved in a dooring incident: The people in charge of vehicles involved must report the accident to the nearest police officer, even if the vehicle was stationary, stopped or parked.
  • Tow and storage businesses: Once the towing law is in force, operators, drivers and storage operators will need the relevant certificates and must follow requirements set by the Act and regulations. The law also sets rules on consent, estimates, invoices, charges, referrals and access to personal property.
  • People using towing or storage services: The law sets protections, including rules on consent and charges. But many details, including permitted amounts, depend on regulations.
  • General public: Automated streetcar enforcement can be used only as provided by the law and regulations. For a ticket based on that system, an owner cannot lose a driver’s licence because of non-payment; a driver convicted on that evidence cannot be imprisoned or put on probation because of the conviction or non-payment.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The towing law allows fees for matters under the Act and authorizes the Director to appoint inspectors, but the material gives no staffing plan or cost estimate.
  • The law allows administrative penalties of up to $100,000; regulations may set lower limits and determine how penalties are calculated.
  • Racing-related impoundment costs are charged to the vehicle’s owner. The Act also allows certificate fees, but does not set their amounts.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not give proclamation dates for provisions that do not start on Royal Assent. The towing law’s main provisions require proclamation.
  • Many towing rules depend on regulations, including certificate qualifications and fees, charge limits, appeals, complaint procedures, and any dispatch service. The law also permits some exemptions.
  • The Act permits regulations to define “race,” “contest” and “stunt.” The supplied material does not say how those terms will be defined.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not verify the full current-law position or how these changes interact with all existing rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce road risks by setting age and equipment limits for power-assisted bicycles and requiring stronger penalties for racing and stunts.
  • Automated streetcar enforcement could provide a way to enforce passing rules while limiting owner liability to cases supported by system evidence.
  • Certification, charge rules and consent requirements could give towing and storage services clearer standards and give users protections against coercion or charges that break the rules.
  • Requiring reports of dooring incidents could help ensure police are told about collisions involving cyclists.

Case against#

  • Important parts of the towing system are left to future regulations, so the Act alone does not show the final requirements, fees or complaint and appeal processes.
  • The Director can set certificate conditions, and inspectors can inspect business premises without a warrant. That gives the system substantial powers; the supplied text does not set out all the practical safeguards or oversight details.
  • Racing-related roadside suspension and impoundment apply before a court conviction and cannot be appealed through a hearing under this section. That can impose costs and disruption even before the court case is decided.
  • The bill authorizes automated streetcar enforcement but leaves many details of evidence, notices and procedures to regulations. The supplied material does not show how those processes will work.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2021053102

    Passed55 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 282

    FOR · 53AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    53For

    • PC36
    • NDP11
    • Liberal6

    2Against

    • Green1
    • New Blue Party of Ontario1