Summary#
Bill 40 would create a new Ontario law called the Garrett’s Legacy Act (Requirements for Movable Soccer Goals), 2018. Its stated goal is to set safety requirements for movable soccer goals.
- An organization or entity that makes a movable soccer goal available to the public must ensure it is on a level surface and securely anchored according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
- If there are no manufacturer’s instructions, outdoor goals must be attached to the ground; indoor goals must be attached to the floor or wall, or secured with weights.
- The Minister may set further requirements by regulation and may appoint inspectors to check compliance.
- The Minister must create a way for members of the public to complain about alleged breaches.
- A person convicted of breaching the anchoring duty could face a fine of up to $500 for each day the breach continues, to a maximum of $5,000.
What it means for you#
- Organizations and entities providing goals for public use: They would have to meet the surface and anchoring requirements. Regulations could add more requirements.
- Members of the public: You would have a way to complain about alleged breaches. The bill does not say how complaints would be handled or what action would follow.
- People responsible for a breach: A person convicted could be fined. The bill does not explain how responsibility would be assigned within an organization or entity.
- Ontario government: The Minister would have to set up the complaint mechanism and could appoint inspectors. The bill does not require inspections on a set schedule.
- The bill does not create a public right to compensation or require every goal to be inspected.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires the Minister to establish a complaint mechanism and allows the Minister to appoint inspectors, but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
- It does not specify an appropriation (money set aside in law) for these duties.
- Fines could be imposed after conviction, but the bill does not estimate how many fines there might be or how much revenue they would raise.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define what counts as “securely” anchored or “level.”
- It does not say when the Act would start; that date would be set by proclamation.
- Any further goal requirements and the inspection rules would depend on regulations, which are not included in the supplied material.
- The bill does not set complaint deadlines, investigation steps, or appeal rights.
- It does not explain how responsibility for a breach would be assigned within an organization or entity.
- The supplied material does not describe existing provincial or local requirements or how they would interact with this Act.
Case for#
- A goal that is securely anchored and placed on a level surface may be less likely to move or fall. This is a possible safety benefit, not a guaranteed result.
- A duty that applies to organizations and entities providing goals for public use gives them a clear responsibility to meet basic requirements.
- Public complaints and possible inspections could help bring alleged breaches to the Minister’s attention.
- Regulations could add requirements if the basic rules in the Act are not enough.
Case against#
- The bill does not define key terms such as “securely,” leaving important details to interpretation or later regulations.
- The Minister may appoint inspectors, but the bill does not require routine inspections or set rules for how complaints must be investigated.
- The Act would make breaches an offence, but does not explain how responsibility would be assigned within an organization or entity.
- The Minister’s required complaint mechanism and any inspections could cost public money, but the bill gives no estimate.