Summary#
Bill 21, the Ministry of Correctional Services Amendment Act (Parole), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of Correctional Services Act. Its stated goal, as described in the explanatory note, is to require parolees to sign their parole conditions and to require electronic location monitoring for certain parolees assessed as a safety risk to their victim.
- A parolee could not begin parole without signing a certificate listing the parole conditions. The bill does not include an exception to this requirement.
- If the Parole Board considers the offence to involve sexual or domestic violence and considers the parolee a safety risk to the victim, location monitoring would be a mandatory parole condition.
- Regulations may set further requirements for monitored parolees. The Board may also set additional conditions about electronic monitoring.
- The bill adds authority to make regulations about requirements for parolees subject to electronic monitoring. It does not itself set out those requirements.
- Parolees granted parole before the new monitoring rule takes effect would not be subject to that rule.
What it means for you#
- People granted parole: You would have to sign a certificate listing your parole conditions before beginning parole. The bill does not provide an exception if you refuse or cannot sign.
- Parolees convicted of sexual or domestic violence: Location monitoring would be required if the Board considers the offence to fall into one of those categories and considers you a safety risk to the victim. The Board could add other conditions about monitoring.
- Victims: The bill does not give victims a new right to information, involvement in parole decisions, or access to monitoring information.
- The Parole Board: It would assess whether the offence fits the bill’s categories and whether the parolee poses a safety risk to the victim. The bill does not set out how those assessments must be made.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires location monitoring in the specified cases but does not say who would provide or pay for it.
- It gives authority to set further requirements by regulation but does not state what those requirements would be or what they would cost.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “sexual violence,” “domestic violence,” or “safety risk.”
- It does not set out the evidence or process the Board must use to make these assessments, or whether and how a parolee could challenge them.
- The bill does not say how location monitoring would work, how long it would last, who would receive location information, or how that information would be protected.
- The bill does not identify the additional requirements that may be set by regulation.
- The bill does not state who would pay for monitoring or give a cost estimate.
- The parent Act was not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the full current law. The explanatory note says the Board can currently release an inmate without a signed certificate in compelling or exceptional circumstances; the bill’s text does not retain that exception.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that monitoring could help track the location of parolees the Board considers a safety risk to the victim.
- The rule would be targeted: monitoring is mandatory only when the Board makes both the offence-category and safety-risk assessments.
- Requiring a signed certificate could make the parole conditions clear to the person before parole begins.
Case against#
- The bill does not define the offence categories or “safety risk,” or set out how the Board must apply them. That leaves important decisions unclear.
- Mandatory monitoring may impose a significant condition even though the bill does not specify its duration, safeguards, or how it relates to the individual risk assessment.
- The bill does not explain how monitoring will be funded or delivered.
- Requiring a signature with no stated exception could prevent someone from beginning parole even in circumstances the current-law explanation describes as compelling or exceptional.