Parole electronic monitoring for sexual or domestic violence

Summary#

Bill 96, Ministry of Correctional Services Amendment Act (Parole), 2023, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of Correctional Services Act. Its goal is to have the Board consider electronic monitoring for certain people released on parole who may pose a safety risk to the victim of a sexual or domestic violence offence.

  • When the Board considers both that the offence involved sexual or domestic violence and that the inmate is a safety risk to the victim, it must consider whether electronic monitoring is appropriate.
  • If the Board decides monitoring is appropriate, it may impose conditions about electronic monitoring. The bill does not require it to impose monitoring.
  • The bill would allow conditions for monitored parolees to be set by regulation.
  • The new rule would not apply to people granted parole before the bill’s section comes into force. The bill says it would start three months after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People on parole: If the Board makes both findings described above, it must consider electronic monitoring. That does not mean monitoring will automatically be imposed. The bill does not change parole eligibility or sentence length.
  • Victims: The bill does not give victims a specific right to request monitoring, take part in the Board’s decision, or receive notice about it.
  • The Board and government: The Board would have a new duty to consider monitoring in the specified cases. Regulations could set conditions for monitored parole.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly create a tax or fee.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost, staffing needs, or savings.

  • The bill would require the Board to consider monitoring in qualifying cases, which could involve administrative work; the bill gives no estimate.
  • It does not set aside a specific amount of money.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “electronic monitoring,” “safety risk,” or what counts as an offence of “sexual or domestic violence.”
  • It does not say what factors the Board must use to decide whether monitoring is appropriate, or how that decision can be challenged.
  • The bill does not specify the monitoring conditions; it leaves these to regulations.
  • The supplied material does not include the full Ministry of Correctional Services Act. I could not verify the Board’s existing powers, definitions, or how the new rule would interact with current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address safety risks to victims after parole is granted.
  • Requiring the Board to consider monitoring in the specified cases could make that option part of the decision, without requiring it in every case.
  • Allowing conditions to be set by regulation could provide a way to spell out the rules for monitoring.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define key terms or spell out how the Board should assess risk and decide whether monitoring is appropriate.
  • Because monitoring is not mandatory, the bill does not ensure that it will be used in any particular case.
  • The bill does not set out safeguards, review steps, or how victims would be involved or informed.
  • The cost and staffing needed to consider and impose monitoring are not stated.