Summary#
Bill 42, the Ministry of Correctional Services Amendment Act (Parole), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of Correctional Services Act. Its stated goal is to require parole certificates to be signed before parole begins and to require location monitoring for some people released on parole.
- The Ontario Parole Board would have to make electronic location monitoring a parole condition when it considers both that the sentence is for an offence of sexual or domestic violence and that the person is a safety risk to the victim.
- The Board could add other conditions about electronic monitoring. Regulations could also set other requirements for people subject to monitoring.
- A person granted parole could not begin parole without signing a certificate that sets out its conditions. The bill removes the current exception described in the explanatory note for compelling or exceptional circumstances.
- The monitoring rule would not apply to people granted parole before that rule comes into force.
- The bill would take effect three months after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People granted parole: You would have to sign your parole certificate before beginning parole. If the Board makes both findings specified in the bill about an offence and risk to its victim, location monitoring would be a condition of parole.
- Victims of the offences covered: The bill does not set out a separate application or notification process for victims, or require the Board to find that every person convicted of such an offence is a safety risk.
- Ontario Parole Board: It would decide whether an offence counts as sexual or domestic violence and whether the person is a safety risk to the victim. If it makes both findings, monitoring would be required.
- General public: The bill does not directly change parole eligibility, sentence length, or the conditions for people who do not meet the monitoring criteria.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost is in the supplied material.
- The bill requires electronic monitoring in cases that meet its criteria, but gives no cost estimate or details about who would pay.
- It allows regulations to set other requirements and the Board to add monitoring conditions, but does not estimate the cost of carrying them out.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “sexual violence,” “domestic violence,” or “safety risk,” or explain how the Board would make those findings.
- It does not specify how monitoring would work, how long it would last, or what happens if equipment fails or a person breaches a monitoring condition.
- The bill does not say who would pay for monitoring or how many people may be affected.
- The supplied text does not establish who would make the regulations or what additional requirements they might set. The parent Act was not supplied, so existing rules and regulatory powers could not be checked.
- The bill gives no start date beyond three months after Royal Assent; the supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to strengthen parole conditions where the Board finds that a person convicted of a sexual or domestic violence offence poses a safety risk to the victim.
- Requiring location monitoring in those cases would make monitoring a condition, rather than leaving it entirely to the Board’s choice.
- Requiring a signed certificate could make clear that a person must sign before parole begins and has received a document setting out the conditions.
Case against#
- The bill does not define the key terms or explain how the Board should assess risk, which could leave important decisions unclear.
- The bill requires monitoring when the Board makes the specified findings, but does not spell out how monitoring would be carried out or what safeguards and review processes would apply.
- A possible trade-off is that the bill removes the signing exception described in the explanatory note, even for cases the Board considers compelling or exceptional.
- The bill creates monitoring duties without providing a cost estimate or identifying who would pay.