Summary#
Bill 57 would create a new Ontario law, the Katelynn’s Principle Act (Decisions Affecting Children), 2016. Its goal is to put children at the centre of decisions affecting them. If enacted, it would require people making decisions under Ontario legislation that affect children to apply eight principles.
- The requirement would cover decisions in areas including child welfare, the justice system and education.
- Decision-makers would have to hear and respect a child’s views, give them weight based on the child’s age and maturity, and offer the child a chance to take part before a decision is made.
- They would have to consider and respect the child’s heritage and the communities the child identifies with.
- The bill says every person providing services to children, or services affecting children, is a child advocate. Advocacy must begin at first contact and continue after that.
- The Act would start on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not say whether Bill 57 passed.
What it means for you#
- Children: For decisions under Ontario legislation that affect them, the principles would require attention to their views, safety, participation and heritage. The bill does not set out a particular application or hearing process.
- People making decisions: Anyone with a power or duty under Ontario legislation to make a decision affecting a child would have to apply the principles.
- People providing services to children: The bill would describe them as child advocates and say advocacy must be ongoing from first contact.
- Families and the public: The bill would not create a new agency, benefit, fine or appeal process. It also would not, on its face, cover every service or policy affecting children; its stated application is to decisions made under Ontario legislation.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires ongoing advocacy by people providing services to children or affecting children, but gives no estimate of staffing or other costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “child advocate” or explain what advocacy requires in practice.
- It does not set out how decision-makers should resolve a conflict between a child’s views and other factors.
- It does not specify how a child’s ability to form views, age or maturity should be assessed.
- It creates no timelines, review or appeal process, reporting duties, or enforcement mechanism for applying the principles.
- The supplied material does not explain how the new requirement would interact with existing rules or services.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address situations where decisions affecting children are made without adequately hearing or protecting them.
- Requiring decision-makers to consider children’s views, age, maturity and heritage could make decisions more responsive to each child.
- Requiring participation before decisions are made could help a child raise concerns while a decision is still being considered.
- Ongoing advocacy from first contact could help keep attention on a child’s interests across services.
Case against#
- The bill sets broad duties but does not explain how to apply them when principles point in different directions.
- Without a defined advocacy role or enforcement process, it is unclear how consistent or accountable application would be.
- The bill requires advocacy to continue but gives no cost estimate or details about who would provide the time and resources.
- The text does not explain how children’s participation would work across different decision settings.