Craft Cider Pricing Cap Bill

Summary#

Bill 53, Growing Ontario’s Craft Cider Industry Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Liquor Control Act; it would not create a separate law or program. Its stated goal is to support Ontario’s craft cider industry by limiting the mark-up or tax the Liquor Control Board of Ontario (the Board) can impose on qualifying Ontario cider.

  • The bill defines “Ontario cider” as cider produced in Ontario from apples or other fruit grown in Ontario. “Cider” also includes perry, a fermented pear-juice beverage.
  • The Board must not impose a mark-up or tax on any class or type of Ontario cider above the mark-up or tax it imposes on any class or type of beer. The limit applies to sales at government stores and elsewhere.
  • No one would be liable to pay any part of a mark-up or tax imposed in breach of that limit.
  • The bill says it would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Ontario cider producers: If their cider meets the bill’s definition, the Board’s mark-up or tax on its sale would be subject to the beer-based limit. The bill does not require retailers to pass any resulting reduction on to producers.
  • Cider buyers: The Board could not collect a mark-up or tax above the limit. The bill does not require a lower retail price.
  • The Board: It would have to follow the limit when imposing a mark-up or tax on covered cider sales.
  • Other cider producers and sellers: The special limit applies to “Ontario cider” as defined in the bill. It does not directly change rules for cider that does not meet that definition.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or require a particular number of staff.
  • If current mark-ups or taxes on covered cider exceed the bill’s limit, the Board could collect less revenue. The amount is unknown.
  • No one would be liable for any portion imposed in breach of the limit.

What is unclear#

  • The Liquor Control Act and its regulations were not supplied, so current mark-ups, taxes, and related rules could not be checked against the bill.
  • The bill does not explain how to compare the mark-up or tax on a cider “class or type” with those on beer “class or type.” The practical comparison rule is unclear.
  • The bill does not define “class or type” or explain whether other definitions in the Act or regulations apply.
  • It does not set out how the Board would identify qualifying cider or handle a disputed classification.
  • The bill does not say whether any reduced Board charge would lead to lower prices for producers or buyers.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would limit the Board’s charges on cider made from Ontario-grown fruit, using beer charges as a ceiling.
  • This could reduce a cost disadvantage for qualifying cider if the Board’s existing charges on it are higher than the applicable limit.
  • The rule covers sales both at government stores and elsewhere, rather than only one sales channel.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not clearly explain how the beer-based limit applies across different classes or types of cider and beer.
  • The bill does not guarantee that any lower Board charge would benefit producers or buyers through lower prices.
  • The limit applies only to cider meeting the bill’s Ontario-cider definition, so other cider would not receive the same rule.
  • The supplied material gives no estimate of any reduction in Board revenue or other financial effect.