Bill would expand spirits sales channels

Summary#

Bill 50, called the Free My Rye Act (Liquor Statute Law Amendment), 2016 in the bill’s short-title clause, would amend Ontario’s Liquor Control Act and Liquor Licence Act. Its apparent goal is to expand sales channels for Canadian spirits and microdistillers.

  • The Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO) would have to ensure that, five years after the change starts, the number of government stores it authorizes to sell Canadian spirits is at least 20% higher than the starting number.
  • The bill would cap the LCBO’s mark-up (the amount added to the price) on spirits it buys from a manufacturer, and the mark-up at a manufacturer’s own retail store, at 10%, 20% or 40% for successive annual volume bands up to 625,000 litres.
  • A manufacturer with a licence to sell spirits to the LCBO could get a separate licence to sell its own spirits in small servings at or beside its production site. The municipality, if there is one, must pass a resolution supporting the licence.
  • Qualifying microdistillers could sell and deliver their spirits to liquor-licensed businesses and permit holders, despite restrictions in agreements made under provincial laws.
  • The Minister would have to publish an annual list of microdistillers and their brands. The bill would start six months after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Spirits buyers: The bill requires more government stores authorized to sell Canadian spirits. It does not require any particular store locations or guarantee lower prices.
  • Microdistillers: To qualify, a producer must hold an LCBO sales licence and generally produce no more than 625,000 litres worldwide in the relevant production year. Rules also apply to production agreements with other manufacturers and to affiliates. Eligible producers could sell and deliver to liquor-licensed businesses and permit holders; the bill does not give them a general right to sell directly to the public.
  • Distillers and visitors: A manufacturer with an LCBO sales licence could seek a licence to sell its own spirits in servings of no more than 43 ml, between 11 a.m. and 11 p.m. Sales must be mainly to promote the product and provide a tourist experience or educational purpose. The municipality must support the licence where a municipality exists.
  • Licensed liquor businesses and permit holders: They could buy and receive spirits from microdistillers, subject to any requirements set by regulation.
  • The LCBO: It would have a duty to meet the five-year store increase and would face the new mark-up caps. The bill does not set out a process for choosing store locations.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill does not state a public cost estimate, appropriation, staffing level or expected revenue change.
  • The LCBO would have to meet the store increase, but the bill does not say what that would cost.
  • The mark-up caps could affect prices or LCBO revenue, but the bill does not say whether prices would change or by how much.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts or full current rules. The explanatory note says some beer and Ontario wine makers can already sell by the glass under regulations, but the current rules and how this bill would interact with them could not be verified.
  • The bill gives no application steps, decision timelines or appeal process for the new onsite licence.
  • Regulations may add conditions to onsite licences and requirements for microdistiller sales. Those details are not in the bill.
  • The mark-up caps list volume bands only up to 625,000 litres; the bill does not state the cap for a manufacturer’s sales above that amount.
  • The bill uses related-company and production tests to decide who qualifies as a microdistiller. Some tests rely on provisions of another Act not supplied here, so their full meaning could not be verified.
  • The supplied title identifies the bill as 2017, while its short-title clause says 2016.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make Canadian spirits available through more government stores and to give qualifying distillers more ways to reach licensed sellers.
  • Lower mark-up ceilings for the listed volume bands could reduce a cost in the sales chain for smaller-volume producers. Whether that would lower consumer prices is not stated.
  • Onsite sales could let distillers offer tastings or educational visits, while limiting servings, hours and location.
  • The annual public list could make it easier to identify qualifying microdistillers and their brands.

Case against#

  • The required store increase could cost money, but the bill gives no estimate and does not specify where stores should be added.
  • Lower mark-up caps do not ensure lower prices for buyers; the bill does not say how any savings must be passed on.
  • The microdistiller tests may exclude producers with certain production agreements or affiliates, even if their own production is below the limit.
  • Onsite sales depend on municipal support and later regulations. The bill does not explain how municipalities would decide whether to support a licence.
  • The bill sets no mark-up cap for volume above 625,000 litres, leaving that part of the pricing rule unclear.