Spirits bill widens sales channels

Summary#

Bill 11, the Free My Rye Act (Liquor Statute Law Amendment), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Liquor Control Act and Liquor Licence Act. Its apparent goal is to expand sales channels for Canadian spirits and give eligible distillers more ways to sell their products. If enacted, it would come into force six months after Royal Assent.

  • The Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO) must ensure that, by the fifth anniversary of the law taking effect, the number of government stores it authorizes to sell Canadian-distilled spirits is at least 20% higher than the starting number.
  • Maximum mark-ups would be set in three volume bands for spirits sold by a manufacturer to the LCBO for resale, or sold at that manufacturer’s own retail store: 10% on the first 50,000 litres, 20% on the next 50,000 litres, and 40% on the next 525,000 litres sold in a year.
  • A spirits manufacturer that meets the bill’s “microdistiller” rules could sell and deliver its spirits to liquor licence or permit holders, despite restrictions in agreements under this or other Acts.
  • A spirits manufacturer with a licence to sell to the LCBO could apply for a licence to sell its own spirits at its production site. A municipal council resolution supporting the licence is required where the site is in a municipality.
  • On-site sales would be limited to areas the manufacturer controls on or next to its production site. They must mainly promote its product and provide a tourism experience or educational purpose; servings could not exceed 43 ml, and sales could only be from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m.

What it means for you#

  • LCBO and government store operators: The LCBO would have a duty to meet the five-year store increase. The bill does not say where the added stores must be or who would operate them.
  • Spirits manufacturers: Eligible producers could face lower maximum mark-ups on the covered sales. Microdistillers could sell and deliver to licensed liquor businesses and permit holders. The bill does not require any manufacturer to use these options.
  • On-site visitors and customers: A licensed producer could sell you its own spirits at its production site under the stated limits. The bill does not guarantee a licence or require a municipality to support one.
  • Municipal councils: A supporting resolution is a precondition for an on-site licence where the site is in a municipality.
  • Licensed liquor businesses and permit holders: They could buy and receive spirits directly from microdistillers under this authority. The bill does not set out how orders or deliveries would work.
  • Consumers: The bill sets limits on mark-ups, not a guaranteed retail price. It does not require manufacturers or retailers to pass any lower mark-up on to customers.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets mark-up ceilings below the mark-up then applying, according to its explanatory note. This could reduce LCBO revenue on covered sales, but the amount is unknown.
  • The LCBO must meet the store-increase target, and the Minister must publish an annual list of microdistillers and their brands. The bill gives no cost estimate or staffing figure for these duties.
  • The bill does not state licence fees or other application costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give the starting store count, explain how the 20% increase would be counted, or set interim targets.
  • The mark-up ceilings cover sales up to 625,000 litres in the listed bands. The text does not set a ceiling for volumes above that amount, or for other types of sales.
  • The rules defining a microdistiller depend on terms and provisions in another Act that were not supplied. The parent Acts were also not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the full current law.
  • The bill does not set out application steps, decision timelines or appeals for the new on-site licence. It allows regulations to add conditions, but those conditions are not provided.
  • The explanatory note says existing regulations allow certain beer and Ontario wine makers to sell by the glass. The supplied material does not show the full current rules or how the new spirits licence would interact with them.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give Canadian spirits more places to be sold by requiring a larger number of authorized government stores.
  • Lower mark-up ceilings could make covered sales more viable for smaller producers, though the bill does not promise lower prices for customers.
  • Direct sales to licensed businesses could give qualifying microdistillers another way to reach customers.
  • On-site sales could let producers promote their products through tourism or education, while limits on product, location, serving size and hours remain.
  • Municipal support is required for on-site licences in municipalities, giving local councils a role in whether they are issued.

Case against#

  • Lower mark-ups could reduce public revenue on covered sales; the bill provides no estimate of the effect.
  • The store target sets a number but does not specify locations or how the added stores would serve customers across the province.
  • The new sales options and store target add duties or permissions without providing cost estimates or detailed implementation rules.
  • The bill allows regulations to add conditions to on-site licences, but those conditions are not in the supplied text. This leaves some operating rules unsettled.