Summary#
Bill 59, the Putting Consumers First Act (Consumer Protection Statute Law Amendment), 2017, was enacted as Ontario’s 2017 Chapter 5. It creates the Home Inspection Act, 2017 and amends consumer, debt-collection and payday-loan laws; its stated goal is to strengthen consumer protection, not to guarantee particular results. The supplied material says some provisions needed a later proclamation to start, but gives no proclamation dates.
- Home inspectors and home-inspection providers must be licensed, and inspections must be based on written contracts and followed by written reports. The Minister may designate an Ontario not-for-profit corporation to administer most of the new Act; if none is designated, the Minister appoints the director and registrar.
- The designated corporation may set and collect fees under processes and criteria approved by the Minister. It is not a Crown agency (part of government), and its workers are not Crown employees. The Act provides for government oversight, including reports, reviews and audits.
- For prescribed goods or services, suppliers generally cannot solicit or enter into certain direct agreements at a consumer’s home unless the consumer specifically asked the supplier to attend for that purpose. A contract made in breach is void, and related agreements are also void. The Act also changes the cooling-off period for direct agreements from 20 days to 10 days after the consumer receives a written copy.
- Suppliers that cash government cheques, other than banks and credit unions, must follow prescribed disclosure rules, stay within a prescribed fee limit and give consumers a statement about the transaction.
- The amendments expand enforcement powers and rules for debt collection and payday loans. They also allow municipalities to limit payday-loan offices in defined areas, but not to ban all such offices across the municipality.
What it means for you#
- Home buyers and consumers: Home inspections must be done by licensed inspectors. The inspector must follow the contract and provide a written report. The Act does not promise a particular inspection standard in the bill itself; many details are left to regulations.
- Consumers approached at home: For prescribed goods or services, a supplier generally cannot solicit or make a direct agreement during a home visit unless you specifically asked the supplier to attend to make that agreement. If the rule is broken, the agreement and related agreements are void; the supplier must reimburse certain related third-party charges.
- People cashing government cheques: Covered suppliers must display prescribed information, provide a statement and charge no more than the limit set by regulation. The bill does not set the dollar limit.
- Borrowers with payday loans: Borrowers may repay part of the outstanding balance early, as well as the full balance. The amendments also allow municipal limits on office locations and numbers. The bill leaves some waiting periods and other borrower protections to regulations.
- Collection agencies and debt buyers: The amendments bring certain purchasers of overdue debts within the definition of a collection agency and require agencies to use due diligence to ensure their collectors comply. An assessor may impose an administrative penalty of up to $10,000 for a prescribed breach. A person may appeal within 15 days; paying the penalty prevents an offence charge for that same breach.
- General public: This Act does not itself set the cheque-cashing fee limit, the home-inspection licensing criteria or many payday-loan rules. Those details depend on regulations.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the available material.
- A designated home-inspection administrator may charge fees, including fees based on each inspection or arrangement, under processes and criteria approved by the Minister. The bill gives no fee amounts or staffing cost.
- The bill authorizes administrative penalties for certain collection-law breaches, up to $10,000, and disciplinary fines for home-inspection licensees, up to $25,000. It does not estimate how much would be collected.
- The bill does not provide an estimate of public spending, compliance costs for businesses or consumers, or savings.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves important details to regulations, including licensing and education requirements, inspection standards, required insurance, cheque-fee limits, and which home-sale solicitations are restricted.
- It permits—but does not require—the government to designate a not-for-profit corporation to administer most of the Home Inspection Act. The supplied material does not say whether one was designated or what fees it would charge.
- The supplied material does not give the proclamation dates for provisions that require them, so it does not establish when each new rule began to operate.
- The parent Acts are not supplied, so I could not verify the amendments against the laws now in force. The explanatory note describes some rules before Bill 59, but not the full current-law context or how all the amendments interact.
- The bill grants broad powers to make later rules on credit agreements and leases, among other subjects. The supplied text does not show what rules were ultimately made.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to set minimum licensing, contract and reporting requirements for a home-inspection industry, with complaints, discipline and inspection powers to enforce them.
- A possible argument for the home-inspection administrator is that a dedicated not-for-profit could handle day-to-day administration while remaining subject to ministerial oversight, public reporting and audit.
- The home-visit restriction could protect consumers from agreements they did not specifically ask a supplier to make at their home. Making a non-compliant agreement void gives the restriction a direct consequence.
- Allowing partial early repayment of payday loans gives borrowers more flexibility than a right limited to paying the whole balance at once.
- Municipalities can respond to local conditions by limiting payday-loan office locations or numbers in defined areas.
Case against#
- Many protections depend on future regulations. Until those details are set, the bill alone does not establish the full inspection standard, fee caps or several lending and lease rules.
- Licensing, administration and compliance could add costs for inspectors, providers and consumers. The bill gives no cost estimate or fee schedule.
- An administrative authority may set and collect fees, and the money it collects is not public money. Although the Act includes oversight, the bill does not state the fees or how administration would be funded in practice.
- Collection penalties can apply even if a person took reasonable steps to prevent a breach or honestly misunderstood the facts. The appeal process provides for written submissions, but the bill does not require a hearing before an initial penalty order.
- Municipal limits may restrict where payday-loan offices can operate, while the bill does not require municipalities to set any limits. The practical effect will depend on local by-laws.