Payday loan rules tighten borrower protections

Summary#

Bill 234, the Payday Loans Accountability Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Payday Loans Act, 2008. Its stated goal is to increase lender accountability and borrower protections. It would set a limit on the maximum interest rate that regulations could allow, require lenders to give borrowers a rights statement, and create an advisory task force.

  • Regulations could not set a maximum monthly interest rate for payday loans if it would make the cost of borrowing exceed 40% on an annual basis. The bill does not itself set the regulations’ rate.
  • Borrowers’ rights principles would have to be considered when interpreting the Act. They cover fair annual interest, fair regulation, transparent dealings, and online dealings with licensed lenders that also have a public-facing office in Ontario and follow the Act and regulations.
  • A lender would have to give the rights statement before entering a payday loan agreement. If it fails, the borrower could rescind (cancel) the agreement within a period set by regulations. The borrower would have to return the advance, and the lender would have to return payments received, with interest calculated under regulations.
  • A Payday Loans Task Force would be established. The Minister would choose its members, including at least 12 people appointed within 60 days of Royal Assent. It would examine other jurisdictions, reasons people use payday loans, alternative products, loan data, interest rates and transparency, then make recommendations.
  • The bill would let regulations define “instalment loan” and set rules for instalment loans and rescission. The task force would also make recommendations on rates for instalment loans and lines of credit.

What it means for you#

  • Borrowers: Before a payday loan agreement, you would have to receive the rights statement. If you do not, the bill would give you a right to cancel within a prescribed time, but you would still have to return the loan advance.
  • People dealing with lenders online: The rights principles refer to online dealings with lenders that meet the stated licence, Ontario office and compliance conditions. The bill does not require lenders to offer online service.
  • Lenders: They would have to provide the statement before payday loan agreements. The bill does not set the rescission deadline or all the steps for using that right.
  • Government: The Minister would appoint the task force. The Lieutenant Governor in Council could set members’ pay and expenses by regulation.

The supplied material does not include the current Payday Loans Act, 2008, so it is not possible to verify how these changes compare with all current rules.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • The bill allows regulations to set pay and expense payments for task force members, but does not require a specific amount.
  • No publicly available information on the cost of staffing or supporting the task force.
  • The lender must return payments received if an agreement is rescinded; the bill says interest must be added, at a rate set by regulations.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the meaning of “instalment loan” to regulations.
  • Regulations would set the rescission period, how a borrower rescinds, the time to return the advance and payments, and the interest calculation.
  • The bill does not explain how the 40% annual limit would be calculated in practice.
  • It does not say whether the Minister must accept or act on the task force’s recommendations, or require that they be made public.
  • The bill does not set out how the task force would access or protect borrower data.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give borrowers clearer information before taking a payday loan and a way to cancel if that information is not provided.
  • A ceiling on the rate regulations may allow could limit how high that rate can be set.
  • The task force could examine the causes of payday loan use and alternatives, alongside loan costs, use and defaults.
  • Including consumer groups, credit experts and payday loan industry representatives could bring different perspectives to its recommendations.

Case against#

  • The 40% limit constrains what regulations may allow, but the bill does not itself set the actual rate borrowers would pay.
  • The cancellation right depends on later regulations for its deadline and practical steps, so the bill alone does not show how easy it would be to use.
  • The task force is advisory. The bill does not require the Minister to follow its recommendations.
  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate or explain how the task force would be funded and supported.