Strengthening Homebuyer Protections Act

Summary#

Bill 166, the Strengthening Protection for Ontario Consumers Act, 2017, was enacted as Chapter 33 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It amends or repeals existing laws and creates three new Acts: the New Home Construction Licensing Act, 2017, the Protection for Owners and Purchasers of New Homes Act, 2017, and the Ticket Sales Act, 2017. Its stated goals include stronger protections for new-home buyers and better-regulated ticket sales; these are goals, not guaranteed results.

  • New-home vendors and builders must be licensed. A new home must also meet the bill’s requirements for confirmation of qualification or enrolment in Ontario’s warranty plan before it can be sold or built.
  • The existing Ontario New Home Warranties Plan continues under a new name. The new law sets out home warranties and protections for money paid, and allows eligible owners to claim compensation from a guarantee fund. Many details are left to regulations.
  • The new home licensing and warranty systems may be administered by designated not-for-profit corporations. If designated, each must administer the provisions assigned to it; each is subject to government oversight and Auditor General audits, but is not a Crown agency.
  • Ticket resellers may list tickets for more than face value, but generally not for more than 50% above face value. A sale above face value must include a full-refund guarantee or a confirmation that the ticket is valid.
  • Ticket businesses must provide specified price, ticket and seller information. The Act also bars certain ticket-buying software and sales of tickets obtained using that software.
  • Other changes include new registration categories and enforcement powers for travel businesses, higher maximum discipline fines in real estate, and related changes to other consumer laws.

What it means for you#

  • Home buyers and owners: A vendor must be licensed and meet the Plan’s requirements before selling a new home. Builders must be licensed and meet enrolment requirements before contracting to build or starting construction. The law sets out warranties, including for Building Code compliance, workmanship, habitability and major defects, but regulations may limit or qualify them.
  • Home buyers and owners: The law protects certain payments and allows compensation claims from the guarantee fund. It does not set out all claim rules or payment limits in the Act itself. The warranty authority must make an ombudsperson available to respond to concerns about its administration.
  • Builders and vendors: They face licensing, disclosure and other requirements, inspections and possible enforcement. The registrar may set licence conditions, and discipline committees may order education, costs or fines of up to $25,000, subject to any lower prescribed limit.
  • Ticket buyers: Before purchase, ticket offers must show required prices and fees, and the seat or standing-area location if applicable. Resale above face value is allowed only within the 50% cap and with the required guarantee or validity confirmation. The charity exception applies to these resale price and guarantee rules.
  • Ticket sellers and platforms: They must disclose required ticket and seller details, cannot offer tickets they do not possess or control, and cannot use or sell software intended to bypass ticket-buying controls. A buyer or ticket business that loses money because of a breach may sue for a remedy.
  • Travel businesses and salespeople: The bill combines travel-agent and travel-wholesaler registration into “travel seller” and creates a registered “travel salesperson” category. It also adds inspection and enforcement powers, including administrative penalties of up to $10,000.
  • General public: This is not one new consumer service. It changes rules, licensing and enforcement across several areas. Some provisions took effect at Royal Assent; the main new-home and ticket Acts were to start on dates set by proclamation. The supplied material does not give those dates.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The new-home authorities may set and collect fees under processes and criteria approved by the Minister. Their government agreements must address financial terms, including licence fees and payments to the Crown.
  • The warranty authority must maintain the guarantee fund and ensure it is adequate for compensation. The law also allows fund payments or loans for certain transition costs.
  • Ticket businesses may face administrative penalties of up to $10,000; ticket-offence fines can reach $50,000 for individuals and $250,000 for corporations. These are maximum penalties, not projected revenue.
  • The bill authorizes staffing through the new-home authorities but gives no staffing numbers or cost estimate. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the regulations that would set many home-warranty limits, exclusions, payment amounts, fees, claim steps and other requirements.
  • It does not identify which not-for-profit corporations would be designated to run the new-home licensing and warranty systems, or when the new Acts would take effect.
  • The bill gives some decision-makers discretion but does not set out all application, investigation or claim timelines and procedures in the Act.
  • The supplied material does not include the full parent Acts or current consolidated laws. I could not verify every change against the law as it stood then or as it stands now.
  • The exact administrative penalties for ticket violations and the detailed rules for travel registration and penalties depend on regulations.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make it harder for unqualified or non-compliant builders and vendors to operate by requiring licences and connecting home sales and construction to warranty-plan requirements.
  • A warranty plan, protected payments and a compensation fund could give buyers routes to seek protection when a new home or transaction fails to meet legal requirements.
  • Ticket-price disclosure, seller identification and refund guarantees could help buyers understand what they are paying for and reduce losses from invalid or misdescribed tickets.
  • Inspection, penalty and court powers could give regulators ways to address breaches without relying only on criminal prosecution.

Case against#

  • A large part of the practical rules depends on later regulations and agreements. Buyers and businesses cannot tell from the Act alone exactly how some protections, fees and claim limits will work.
  • The new-home authorities may be private not-for-profit corporations exercising delegated public functions. Although the bill provides for audits, reporting and Ministerial oversight, they are not Crown agencies, and the Crown is generally shielded from liability for their actions.
  • The ticket price cap and refund rules may not prevent every buyer loss; the bill’s guarantee and cap provisions do not apply to sales for the benefit of a registered charity.
  • The bill creates broad inspection and enforcement powers, including some inspections without a warrant. The Act provides limits and hearing or appeal routes for certain decisions, but the process may still be burdensome for affected businesses.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017121301

    Passed93 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 166

    FOR · 50AGAINST · 43

    50For

    • Liberal50

    43Against

    • PC25
    • NDP17
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017111501

    Passed83 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 166, An Act to amend or repeal various Acts and to enact three new Acts with respect to the construction of new homes…

    FOR · 47AGAINST · 36

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    47For

    • Liberal47

    36Against

    • PC22
    • NDP14
  3. Division No. 2017110101

    Passed92 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 166

    FOR · 50AGAINST · 42

    50For

    • Liberal50

    42Against

    • PC25
    • NDP16
    • Independent1
  4. Division No. 2017110102

    Passed92 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 166

    FOR · 91AGAINST · 1

    91For

    • Liberal50
    • PC25
    • NDP16

    1Against

    • Independent1