Bill sets carbon budgets and targets

Summary#

Bill 62, the Climate Change Mitigation and Low-carbon Economy Amendment Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Climate Change Mitigation and Low-carbon Economy Act, 2016. Its stated goal is to set greenhouse gas reduction targets and require carbon budgets and climate-adaptation planning; those requirements would not take effect unless the bill became law and was brought into force by proclamation.

  • It would set province-wide targets, measured against 1990 emissions: at least 15% lower by 2020, 45% by 2030 and 80% by 2040. The Lieutenant Governor in Council could increase the targets by regulation, including in response to climate science.
  • The Environment Minister would have to introduce a bill in the Legislature for each carbon budget period: 2018–2020, then successive five-year periods. Each proposed budget would include an emissions limit, targets by greenhouse gas and economic sector, expected reductions from government programs, and estimated government costs.
  • If a period’s emissions limit were exceeded, the Minister would have to introduce a bill to lower the next period’s limit by at least twice the amount of the excess, after obtaining and considering advice from the Environmental Commissioner.
  • The Minister would have to establish an adaptation program for each period and introduce a bill providing for it. The program would address protection of life, property and biodiversity, and assistance for people affected by reduced fossil-fuel reliance or climate change.
  • The Minister would have to report each year on emissions-reduction progress and climate risks. The Environmental Commissioner would audit those reports, and the Minister would have to present the audit results to the Legislature.

What it means for you#

  • People and businesses: The bill sets province-wide targets and requires sector targets in future carbon budgets. It does not itself impose emissions limits or other direct duties on individual people or businesses.
  • Workers and people affected by climate change: Future adaptation programs would have to include objectives for assistance to people whose employment is affected by reduced fossil-fuel reliance, and to people, communities and businesses harmed by climate change. The bill does not specify who qualifies or what assistance they would receive.
  • The Environment Minister and Environmental Commissioner: The Minister would have to prepare annual reports, develop budgets and adaptation programs, and introduce bills. The Commissioner would have to advise on proposed corrective budgets and audit the annual reports.
  • Taxpayers: Future budgets and adaptation proposals would have to include estimated government costs. The bill does not provide those estimates.
  • The Legislature: Introducing a bill would not itself make a carbon budget or adaptation program law. The Legislature would still have to consider and pass the bills.

Money#

The bill requires cost estimates in future carbon budgets and adaptation proposals, but the available material gives no overall cost estimate.

  • It does not specify an appropriation (a legal authorization to spend public money), staffing levels, or program budgets.
  • The bill would require government reports and audits, but their costs are not stated.
  • It does not set a tax, fee, fine or direct payment to individuals.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the current-law baseline and how these provisions fit with existing requirements could not be independently verified.
  • The bill does not set rules for how emissions are measured, how budgets would be enforced, or what happens if a proposed budget bill is not passed.
  • It does not define eligibility, amounts or delivery methods for adaptation assistance.
  • It does not say how the Minister would choose policies, or how the government would respond to the risks identified in annual reports.
  • The bill says the Minister must publish material considered before introducing a budget bill, but its cross-reference points to the provision about exceeding a budget, rather than the provision listing the matters to consider.
  • The bill would start only on a day set by proclamation; no start date is given in the supplied text.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that fixed targets and regular carbon budgets would make the government’s planned emissions limits and expected program results more specific and visible.
  • Requiring targets by sector and by type of greenhouse gas could make it easier to compare plans with reported progress.
  • Annual reporting and independent audits could give the Legislature information about progress and climate risks.
  • The required adaptation program would make protection and assistance part of the government’s planning, not only emissions reduction.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires plans and bills, but does not itself ensure that the Legislature passes them or that planned measures are carried out.
  • The automatic requirement to propose a next-period limit at least twice as low as an overshot limit could lead to a demanding correction, without the bill specifying how it would be met.
  • The bill requires consideration of economic, fiscal and social effects, including fuel poverty, but does not say how those concerns should be weighed against emissions targets.
  • The required planning, reports and audits would take public resources, but the bill does not estimate those costs or specify staffing.