Summary#
Bill 165, the Ontario Climate Crisis Strategy for the Public Sector Act, 2019, would create a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would require the Lieutenant Governor in Council to establish a public-sector climate strategy. The stated goal is to set a plan for cutting emissions and energy use in the public sector.
- The strategy must include a plan to cap greenhouse gas emissions from public-sector activities within 12 months after the strategy takes effect, then reduce them by at least 5% each year until they reach net zero.
- The plan must cover activities involving facilities that are owned, leased, operated or primarily funded by the public sector, including housing; public-sector-owned vehicles; and the integrated power system.
- For covered new facilities, the strategy must set a goal of using at least 50% less energy than an average comparable new private-sector facility for construction starting on or after the Act’s second anniversary. For construction starting on or after its fifth anniversary, the goal is net-zero energy consumption.
- The strategy must provide for government programs encouraging facility retrofits and more environmentally friendly public-sector vehicles, and purchasing guidelines for the public sector. Those guidelines must use greenhouse gas emissions as a proposal-evaluation criterion and disqualify proposals that exceed other proposals’ emissions by a specified percentage, capped at 10%.
- The responsible Minister must publish reports on public-sector energy use and reductions, energy use at new or retrofitted facilities, and any other matters set by regulation. Each report must be audited under rules set by regulation.
What it means for you#
- Public-sector organizations: The bill would require the government to create a strategy and the Minister to publish and audit reports. The emissions and energy targets are goals the strategy must plan to achieve; the bill does not directly require each organization to meet a specific target.
- Public-sector facilities and vehicle operators: The strategy must include programs encouraging retrofits and cleaner vehicles. The bill does not itself require a particular facility or vehicle to be upgraded.
- Businesses seeking public-sector contracts: The strategy must include purchasing guidelines with emissions as a proposal-evaluation criterion and a disqualification rule. The bill does not set out how a procurement would be run or how proposals would be compared.
- The public: The strategy and reports are to be made available publicly. The bill does not create a new front-line service, tax, fee or benefit.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires the Minister to prepare, publish and arrange audits of reports, and requires the government to establish the strategy. It does not estimate the cost or specify staffing.
- The strategy must provide for programs encouraging retrofits and vehicle changes, but the bill does not set a program budget or require a particular amount of spending.
- The bill does not specify who would pay for facility or vehicle changes, or estimate procurement or construction costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill defines “public sector” by reference to the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996, but does not list the organizations covered. The text of that Act was not supplied, so the scope cannot be verified here.
- The bill does not say how the strategy’s emissions goals would be enforced, or what happens if they are missed.
- It leaves key details to regulations, including how facility energy use and proposal emissions are measured, how reports are prepared and audited, and what additional goals or initiatives may be added.
- It does not explain how procurement guidelines would compare proposals or what “a given percentage more” means in practice.
- It allows the strategy to set its own effective date, subject to a deadline of no later than one year after Royal Assent. It does not specify when the strategy must be updated or how the public can comment on it.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that government can set targets for its own activities and use public reporting to show energy use and progress.
- The strategy would cover several sources of public-sector emissions, including buildings, vehicles and the integrated power system.
- Energy-use goals for new facilities could encourage lower-energy construction, while procurement rules could make emissions relevant when public bodies choose proposals.
- The bill requires public reports and audits, which could make energy use and reported reductions more visible.
Case against#
- The bill sets goals for the strategy to plan toward, but does not directly require public-sector organizations to meet the emissions or energy targets. The text does not explain what would happen if progress falls short.
- The strategy must include programs encouraging changes, but the bill does not specify funding, delivery rules or who would be responsible for carrying them out.
- The measurement rules and procurement details are left to regulations, so the bill alone does not show how targets or proposal disqualifications would work.
- Reaching the stated facility and emissions goals could require spending, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding plan.