Bill would create climate-health action plan

Summary#

Bill 14, No Time to Waste Act (Plan for Climate Action and Jobs), 2022, would create three new Acts; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to prepare health services and the public sector for climate-related risks and to develop a wider proposal to address climate threats.

  • The Health Minister must publish a climate-and-health action plan within two years, review it at least every four years, and consult specified groups when developing or revising it.
  • The Minister must establish a Climate Crisis and Health Secretariat, whose work is directed by the Health and Environment Ministers, and a science advisory board of 10 to 20 appointed members.
  • The plan must include research programs, health-risk monitoring, priority infrastructure projects, and a plan for funding and guidance to help public health units and health care facilities assess risks and plan for climate impacts.
  • The government must establish a public-sector climate strategy within one year. It must set out goals for capping public-sector greenhouse-gas emissions, reducing them by at least 5% each year until net zero, and reducing energy use at new public-sector facilities.
  • The strategy must include public-sector purchasing guidelines that consider emissions and can disqualify proposals that exceed another proposal’s emissions by a set percentage, capped at 10%. Annual public reports on public-sector energy use must be audited.
  • The bill would also establish a Legislative Assembly select committee, with up to nine members, to report within six months with a proposal addressing climate threats, including threats to Indigenous, racialized and low-income Ontarians.

What it means for you#

  • Public health and health care organizations: The health plan must include communication strategies, monitoring, research, and a plan for funding and guidance to help public health units and health care facilities assess their climate risks. The bill does not itself set the amount of funding.
  • Public-sector bodies: The strategy must set out emissions and energy-use goals and purchasing guidelines. It must cover emissions from specified activities, including public-sector facilities, vehicles and the electricity system. The bill does not directly require each body to meet a specific emissions target.
  • Health professionals, communities and the public: The health plan must identify vulnerable groups and health risks, and set out ways to communicate strategies. The Minister must consult specified groups, including First Nations, Inuit, Métis and Black representatives, municipalities, health organizations and communities most at risk.
  • General public: The strategy’s annual energy reports and the health action plan must be made public. The select committee must report, but the bill does not require the government to adopt or implement its proposal.
  • The bill does not create a new health-care service or guarantee jobs. It does not change a tax, fee or benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires new work by ministers, a Secretariat, an advisory board and a select committee, but gives no staffing or cost estimates.
  • The health plan must include a plan for funding and guidance; this is not itself a specified funding amount or appropriation.
  • The public-sector strategy must include programs to encourage retrofits and cleaner vehicles, but the bill sets no budget for them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define key terms such as “net zero” or explain how public-sector emissions will be counted.
  • Regulations are needed for some details, including how facility energy comparisons and purchasing emissions will be measured, and how reports will be audited.
  • The bill sets goals for the public-sector strategy, but does not specify penalties or other consequences if public-sector bodies do not meet them.
  • The strategy is not subject to Part III of the Legislation Act, 2006, which applies to regulations. The bill does not set out a public consultation process for creating or changing the strategy.
  • The bill does not say how much funding would go to health facilities, what programs would be created, or how Indigenous communities would take part beyond consultation and technical support.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make climate-related health risks part of health-system planning, with monitoring, research and advice from scientists and health professionals.
  • Requiring a plan to identify vulnerable communities and communicate health risks could help public agencies prepare for risks such as extreme heat, poor air quality and infectious disease.
  • A public-sector strategy could use government facilities, vehicles and purchasing as areas for setting climate and energy goals.
  • A select committee proposal could bring climate-related risks to society, the environment and the economy into one report.

Case against#

  • The bill requires plans and goals, but leaves many methods and measures to future regulations or government decisions. The public-sector goals do not, by themselves, specify direct penalties for failing to meet them.
  • It requires new offices, research and reporting work without stating the staffing or costs, or how health-plan funding would be provided.
  • The bill does not set out how the strategy will be developed with public input or how progress toward its goals will be enforced.
  • The select committee must produce a proposal, but there is no requirement to act on it.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2022112101

    Defeated102 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 14

    AGAINST · 72FOR · 30

    72Against

    • PC72

    30For

    • NDP23
    • Liberal6
    • Green1