Summary#
Bill 193, the Climate Crisis Health Action Plan Act, 2020, would create a new Act; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to prepare Ontario’s public health and health care systems for health risks caused by the climate crisis.
- The Minister of Health would have to publish a strategic action plan within two years of Royal Assent, then review it at least every four years and make changes the Minister considers necessary.
- The plan would have to identify health risks and vulnerable communities; set out public communications and research programs; identify priority health infrastructure projects; plan funding and guidance for public health units and health care facilities; and include modelling, forecasting and health-monitoring systems.
- The Minister would have to establish a Climate Crisis and Health Secretariat and a science advisory board. The board would have 10 to 20 minister-appointed members with expertise in public health, health care services or climate science.
- When developing or revising the plan, the Minister would have to consider the board’s latest scientific advice and consult listed groups, including First Nations, Inuit, Métis and Black communities, municipalities, scientists, health organizations and at-risk communities.
- As directed by the Health and Environment ministers, the Secretariat would assist with the plan, gather and share information, track environmental data, expand modelling, do research, identify high-risk places and groups, communicate risks, build partnerships, advise organizations, support municipalities and Indigenous communities, develop response plans and training, and carry out other functions those ministers consider advisable.
What it means for you#
- Public and health care organizations: The plan would have to include communication strategies for health organizations, facilities, health professionals and the public. The bill does not require individuals or health organizations to apply for a review or meet new standards.
- Public health units and health care facilities: The plan would have to set out a plan for funding and guidance to help them assess vulnerabilities and develop climate adaptation plans. The bill does not itself specify grants, amounts or eligibility rules.
- Municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities: If directed by the ministers, the Secretariat would have to provide technical assistance and support on assessing preparedness and response strategies.
- Communities named in the bill: The plan would have to identify vulnerable populations. Its monitoring systems would cover, among other things, health effects on Indigenous, Black and racialized people, migrants, refugees, displaced people and low-income communities. The bill does not create an individual benefit or service for these groups.
- Researchers and health and climate experts: The board would advise the Minister; its members would be appointed by the Minister. The bill does not give the board decision-making power over the plan.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost.
- The bill would require a Secretariat and a science advisory board, but gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
- The plan would have to include a plan for funding and guidance to public health units and health care facilities. The bill does not set funding amounts or appropriate money.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define terms such as “climate crisis,” “vulnerable” or “critical priority.”
- It does not set out the Secretariat’s staffing, budget or internal structure, or rules for choosing its members.
- It does not specify how funding in the action plan would be allocated, who would qualify, or when funding would be available.
- It does not set detailed targets, deadlines or measures for carrying out the plan, beyond its initial publication deadline and four-year reviews.
- It does not explain how the Secretariat’s work would fit with existing programs or how its advice and performance would be made public.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make health risks part of climate planning, including extreme heat, disease, poor air or water quality, severe weather and disruptions to medical care.
- A recurring plan, monitoring systems and scientific advice could help the government identify changing risks and update its response.
- Requiring consultation with at-risk communities and health organizations could bring affected groups’ experience into planning.
- A Secretariat with research, communication and support duties could help connect health agencies, municipalities and Indigenous communities.
Case against#
- The bill requires planning and a set of functions, but does not set funding levels, deadlines for most actions or measurable results. A plan could be published without resolving how it will be carried out.
- The Secretariat’s duties depend on direction from the Health and Environment ministers, and those ministers may assign it other functions. The bill does not spell out how its priorities would be set or reviewed.
- The bill requires consultation but does not say how input must affect the plan or how the government should explain its decisions.
- The bill calls for new staff, research, monitoring, training and support, but provides no cost estimate. It is therefore unclear what resources these duties would require.