Summary#
Bill 94, the Climate Crisis Health Action Plan Act, 2022, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. It would require the Minister of Health to create a public plan for preparing Ontario’s health and public health systems for climate-related health risks. The stated goal is to improve that preparedness, not to guarantee any particular health outcome.
- Within two years of Royal Assent, the Minister must publish a plan identifying health risks and vulnerable communities. The plan must include research programs, monitoring systems, communication strategies, and a plan for funding and guiding public health units and health care facilities.
- The Minister must establish a Climate Crisis and Health Secretariat. Directed by the Health and Environment ministers, it must carry out listed work, including research, risk monitoring, public communication, technical support for municipalities and Indigenous communities, and preparedness plans and training.
- The Minister must appoint a science advisory board of 10 to 20 members with expertise in public health, health care, or climate science. It must advise the Minister.
- The Minister must consult specified groups when developing or revising the plan, including First Nations, Inuit, Métis and Black community representatives, municipalities, health organizations, scientists, and at-risk communities.
- The Minister must review the plan at least every four years and make changes considered necessary. Regulations may set rules for implementing it and for the board.
What it means for you#
- People in Ontario: The bill would create government planning and monitoring duties, including for risks such as extreme heat, infectious disease, air and water quality, food insecurity, and disruptions to medical care. It would not create a personal health-care benefit, new right to treatment, or individual application process.
- Public health units and health care facilities: The plan must set out how funding and guidance would be provided so they can assess vulnerabilities and develop adaptation plans. The bill does not itself set funding amounts or require a particular facility to receive funding.
- Municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities: The Secretariat must provide technical assistance and support in assessing preparedness and response strategies. The bill does not specify how much support, or when it must be provided.
- Health professionals, researchers and public health organizations: They may be affected by the plan’s communication, research, monitoring and training measures. The bill does not set out the detailed programs or training requirements.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires the plan to include government research programs and a plan for funding and guidance, but gives no budget or funding amount.
- It requires a Secretariat and a science advisory board, but gives no staffing numbers, operating costs, or member compensation details.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define key terms such as “climate crisis,” “vulnerable,” or “greatest risk.”
- It does not specify the Secretariat’s size, budget, or how it will carry out its broad list of duties.
- The plan must include programs and a funding plan, but the bill does not name the programs, set funding levels, or say how funding decisions would be made.
- It does not set timelines or procedures for the Secretariat’s support, training, monitoring, or preparedness work.
- It does not explain how this work would fit with existing programs or who would oversee whether the plan is carried out.
- The bill says it would start on Royal Assent. Whether it has become law is not stated in the supplied material.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address health risks that may affect many parts of the health system, rather than treating each risk as an isolated emergency.
- A single public plan, reviewed at least every four years, could help government and health organizations coordinate planning and update it as scientific advice changes.
- The required monitoring could help identify emerging risks and the communities facing them.
- The Secretariat’s research, communication, technical support and training duties could give public health and health care organizations more help preparing for these risks.
Case against#
- The bill requires planning and broad duties but does not set budgets, staffing levels, service standards, or deadlines for most of the work. The practical level of action is therefore uncertain.
- The Minister directs the Secretariat’s work, and the Minister appoints the advisory board; the bill does not specify how the board’s advice would be made public or how disagreements would be handled.
- The bill does not set out how the required funding would be allocated or ensure that the named communities and institutions receive support.
- The Secretariat’s duty to perform other functions a minister considers advisable is broad, while the bill gives few details about oversight of its work.