Summary#
Bill 85, Protecting Passenger Safety Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. It would set fines for specified offences involving transporting passengers for compensation without required authorization, and add licence-suspension and vehicle-impoundment rules for repeat offences. Its stated goal is to promote compliance and safeguard the public.
- A person convicted of contravening specified parts of section 39.1 would face a fine of $500 to $30,000.
- If the required demerit-point regulation is in place, the Registrar must record three points for a conviction under section 39.1(1).
- For a suspected offence under section 39.1(1), if the officer has reasonable and probable grounds and determines the driver was convicted of the same offence in the previous five years, the officer must request the driver’s licence and detain the vehicle.
- The licence would be suspended for 30 days from the request. The vehicle would be impounded for 30 days from detention, at the owner’s cost and risk.
- The bill allows impoundment to run at the same time as certain other impoundments. It also allows regulations for record-keeping and reporting, and exemptions for specified classes of people or vehicles.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Drivers: If you are convicted of an offence under section 39.1(1), three demerit points would be recorded only if a regulation providing for a demerit-point system has been made. If the repeat-offence conditions are met, your licence would be suspended for 30 days.
- Vehicle owners: You would have to bear the cost and risk of removal and impoundment, even if someone else was driving. The storage operator could keep the vehicle until those costs are paid. An owner may sue the driver to recover costs or other losses.
- Drivers and vehicle owners: There would be no appeal or right to be heard before the suspension, detention or impoundment. An officer may release the vehicle early if satisfied it was stolen when it was driven.
- People transporting passengers for compensation: The bill changes penalties and enforcement for the specified offences. The supplied material does not show the full current rules in section 39.1.
- General public: The bill says the suspension and impoundment are meant to promote compliance and public safety. It does not create a new passenger service or guarantee a particular safety result.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s total public cost or expected savings.
- Vehicle owners would bear removal and impound costs; the bill gives no amounts.
- The fine for the specified section 39.1 offences would be $500 to $30,000.
- Obstructing or interfering with an officer carrying out these duties would carry a fine of $200 to $5,000, up to six months in jail, or both.
- The bill requires no stated number of staff and provides no estimate for enforcement or administration.
What is unclear#
- The Highway Traffic Act itself was not supplied, so the current penalties and full requirements in section 39.1 could not be checked against current law.
- The bill does not set out how much removal or storage will cost, or who sets those charges.
- It does not explain how a driver or owner could challenge an officer’s decision; it expressly removes a right to appeal or be heard before the listed actions.
- The demerit-point change depends on a regulation being made. The supplied text does not say whether or when that will happen.
- The bill permits regulations for exemptions, but does not identify which people or vehicles might qualify.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to deter people from repeatedly transporting passengers for compensation without the required licence, permit or authorization.
- A 30-day suspension and impoundment would impose immediate consequences when an officer has reasonable and probable grounds and the driver has a recent conviction.
- The bill states that these measures are intended to promote compliance and safeguard the public.
- Making impoundment concurrent with certain other impoundments avoids adding a separate 30-day period on top of those listed impoundments.
Case against#
- A licence suspension and vehicle impoundment can begin without a prior hearing, and the bill provides no appeal from those actions.
- An owner may face costs and loss of use even when someone else was driving. The owner can sue the driver, but the bill does not ensure the owner will recover the money.
- The bill does not set limits on removal or storage charges or give details of how officers’ decisions will be reviewed.
- The fine range is substantial, but the supplied material does not explain how fines would be set within that range.