Higher fines for carrying passengers for pay

Summary#

Bill 170, the Protecting Passenger Safety Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. It would raise fines for carrying a passenger for compensation without a required licence, permit or authorization, and add penalties for repeat alleged offences. Its stated goal is to promote compliance with the Act and safeguard the public.

  • A person convicted of an offence under the listed parts of section 39.1 would face a fine of $500 to $30,000.
  • If a regulation establishing a demerit-point system is in place, a person convicted under section 39.1(1) would receive three points.
  • For a suspected breach of section 39.1(1), if the driver was convicted of the same offence within the previous five years, an officer must suspend the driver’s licence and detain the vehicle. The suspension and impoundment last 30 days.
  • The vehicle’s owner bears the removal and impound costs and the risk of the impoundment. An officer may release the vehicle early if satisfied it was stolen when used.
  • Obstructing an officer carrying out these duties would be an offence, punishable by a $200–$5,000 fine, up to six months in jail, or both.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers carrying passengers for compensation: The bill does not change the licensing requirement described in the explanatory note. It raises the fine for offences under specified parts of section 39.1. For a conviction under subsection (1), three demerit points apply only if a regulation has established a demerit-point system.
  • Drivers with a recent conviction: If an officer has reasonable and probable grounds to believe you committed a new breach of subsection (1), and determines you were convicted of the same offence in the past five years, the officer must request your licence and detain the vehicle. The 30-day suspension takes effect when requested; the 30-day impoundment starts when the vehicle is detained. There is no appeal or right to be heard before these measures.
  • Vehicle owners: You may have to pay removal and impound costs before the vehicle is released. Those costs are a lien on the vehicle. An owner may sue the driver to recover costs or other losses from the impoundment.
  • Police and appointed officers: They must carry out the specified detention and suspension steps when the conditions are met, keep records and provide notices. The bill allows regulations to set further record and reporting rules and to create exemptions.
  • Other drivers and passengers: The bill does not directly change general licensing rules, fares, or passenger rights.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied materials.

  • Vehicle owners must bear removal and impound costs; the bill does not set their amount.
  • The bill creates enforcement and record-keeping duties but gives no estimate of staffing or other public costs.
  • The bill changes fines but does not say how any fine revenue would be used.

What is unclear#

  • The Highway Traffic Act itself was not supplied, so the current fine amounts and the full wording of the existing section 39.1 could not be checked against current law.
  • The bill does not say whether a demerit-point regulation is in place or when one would be made.
  • It does not set removal or storage rates, or explain how an owner can challenge costs.
  • It does not provide a hearing or appeal for the suspension or impoundment. It also does not explain how officers should handle disputes about identity, ownership, or the prior conviction.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied materials explains how often the new powers might be used or their total cost.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to deter carrying passengers for compensation without the required authorization, by raising the possible fine.
  • A mandatory licence suspension and vehicle impoundment for a suspected repeat offence could be seen as a way to respond quickly rather than wait for a conviction on the new allegation.
  • The bill’s stated aim is to promote compliance and safeguard the public.

Case against#

  • The suspension and impoundment can begin based on an officer’s grounds and a prior conviction, before a court decides whether the new alleged offence occurred. The bill provides no appeal or advance hearing.
  • The vehicle owner bears costs and risk even if someone else was driving. The bill allows the owner to sue the driver, but does not guarantee recovery.
  • The bill does not set impound costs or explain how officers’ use of the powers will be monitored.