New offence protects vulnerable road users

Summary#

Bill 37, the Protecting Vulnerable Road Users Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act by creating a new offence and adding sentencing rules. Its stated goal is to strengthen the legal consequences when a driver’s breach of specified road rules causes or contributes to a vulnerable road user’s death or serious bodily harm.

  • The offence would apply to drivers of motor vehicles, but not drivers of motor-assisted bicycles. It covers pedestrians, people on bicycles or using mobility devices, certain highway workers and emergency responders outside specified vehicles, and anyone later added by regulation.
  • The new offence would apply only when the driver’s conduct involves one or more listed Highway Traffic Act provisions. The bill says it would not be an absolute-liability offence (one where the prosecution generally need not prove fault).
  • A convicted driver would face the penalty and other consequences for the underlying road-rule violation, plus a mandatory probation order lasting up to one year. The order must require a driving course and 50 to 200 hours of community service, including activity related to driving safety.
  • The driver’s licence would be suspended for the length of probation. The driver must attend sentencing in person, and the court must consider relevant victim impact statements.
  • A court could extend probation by up to one more year in certain cases where the driver fails to complete the course or service but shows good cause. A separate conviction for breaching the probation order could bring a fine of up to $50,000; the court may also suspend a licence or permit for up to two years.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers: The new consequences would apply only if the driver is convicted of the new offence—not to every collision involving serious injury or death. A proceeding must start through a court information, not a certificate of offence.
  • Vulnerable road users and affected people: The bill would let a person who suffered or claims harm, loss, or property damage present an impact statement. This includes someone affected by an offence against another person.
  • The public: The bill would not itself change the listed road rules or create a compensation benefit. Its main change is to add an offence and consequences when specified rules are broken and the required serious harm results.
  • Regulations: The Lieutenant Governor in Council could add people to the protected group and set requirements for driving courses.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires a driving course and community service for convicted drivers, but it does not say who pays for the course or estimate costs.
  • It requires in-person attendance at sentencing and changes how these cases are started. No publicly available information gives the added court or enforcement costs.
  • The bill sets a maximum fine for breaching probation, but does not estimate fine revenue.

What is unclear#

  • “Serious bodily harm” is not defined in the supplied text.
  • The bill lists many Highway Traffic Act provisions, but the parent Act was not supplied. I could not verify the exact conduct covered by each provision, or the existing penalties and consequences for breaching them.
  • The bill does not specify who provides the driving course, how it is paid for, or how community service is arranged.
  • It does not say how the additional people who may be prescribed by regulation would be chosen, or when the regulation would be made.
  • The supplied text says most of the bill would start six months after Royal Assent; several amendments would start on a date set by proclamation. The materials do not give those dates or the bill’s current status.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to add consequences when a driver’s breach of specified road rules causes death or serious bodily harm, rather than treating the event only as an ordinary traffic violation.
  • A possible argument for the mandatory course and safety-related community service is that they directly address driving conduct and public safety.
  • Requiring the driver to attend sentencing and requiring the court to consider impact statements could make the harm caused more visible in sentencing.

Case against#

  • A mandatory licence suspension and probation conditions would apply to every conviction under the new offence, with no exception stated in the bill for individual circumstances.
  • The bill does not explain how course costs, course availability, or community-service arrangements would work.
  • Because the key harm threshold is undefined in the supplied text, its application may be unclear.
  • The bill adds court and enforcement duties without providing a cost estimate or explaining how those duties would be resourced.