Bill would study credential recognition for immigrants

Summary#

Bill 98 would create a new law, the Fairness for Ontario’s Internationally Trained Workers Act, 2022. It would require two ministers to establish advisory committees, publish their recommendations, and report to the Legislative Assembly on progress. The stated aim is to create a framework for recognizing internationally trained workers; the bill does not itself change credential or licensing rules.

  • The Labour Minister must establish a Foreign Credential Recognition Advisory Committee within 90 days after the Act comes into force. It must include representatives of immigrant-serving settlement organizations, language access organizations and internationally educated non-regulated professionals.
  • That committee must examine credential-recognition pathways, fair hiring practices and support for immigrant-serving agencies, then make recommendations to the Labour Minister.
  • The Health Minister must establish a healthcare professions advisory committee within the same 90-day period. It must include representatives of relevant regulators and licensing bodies, Ontario bridging or continuing-education programs, associations of internationally trained healthcare professionals, and healthcare labour unions and associations.
  • The healthcare committee must examine practice-ready pathways, clinical-experience programs for internationally trained physicians seeking licences, and fair hiring practices, then make recommendations to the Health Minister.
  • The ministers must publish the committees’ recommendations in English, French and any additional languages chosen by each committee. Each minister must also submit a progress report to the Legislative Assembly within one year of establishing their committee.

What it means for you#

  • Internationally trained non-regulated professionals: A committee must examine ways to recognize credentials and address hiring practices. The bill does not give individuals a new right to have credentials recognized or require employers to change hiring practices.
  • Internationally trained healthcare professionals: A committee must examine possible training and clinical-experience pathways and fair hiring. The bill does not create those pathways, change licensing requirements or guarantee a licence or job.
  • Regulators, licensing bodies, education programs and unions: Representatives from specified groups must be included on the healthcare committee. The bill does not require these organizations to adopt the committee’s recommendations.
  • Employers: The bill creates no new employer duty, hiring rule or penalty.
  • The public: Recommendations must be published in English, French and any additional languages selected by the committees. The bill does not require the ministers to implement the recommendations.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee members’ pay and expenses, but only if the Legislature has appropriated money for that purpose.
  • The ministers must establish committees, publish recommendations and prepare progress reports. The bill gives no estimate for the cost of those duties, including staff or translation.
  • No funding for credential-recognition or healthcare training programs is provided in the bill.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set committee size, selection criteria beyond the required groups, meeting rules or deadlines for making recommendations.
  • It does not say when recommendations must be published after they are made, or how progress reports must assess progress.
  • It does not define key terms such as “practice-ready pathways” or “fair and non-discriminatory hiring practices.”
  • It does not explain how recommendations would interact with existing licensing, credential-recognition or employment programs.
  • The supplied material does not establish the bill’s current legislative status.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives ministers a formal way to examine barriers affecting both non-regulated professionals and regulated healthcare workers.
  • Required representation from affected professionals, immigrant-serving groups, regulators, educators and labour organizations could bring different perspectives into that work.
  • Publishing recommendations in additional languages could make them accessible to more people.
  • Requiring ministers to report to the Legislature would make them explain what progress has been made, even though they are not required to adopt the recommendations.

Case against#

  • The committees can recommend changes, but the bill does not require ministers, regulators or employers to make them.
  • The bill does not itself create credential-recognition routes, clinical placements or training programs, so it may not directly remove the barriers described in its preamble.
  • The bill leaves important details—such as timelines for recommendations, committee procedures and the meaning of “practice-ready”—to be worked out later.
  • Committee pay and expenses may be set only if money is appropriated, but the available material gives no overall cost estimate.