Wine tax exemption at winery stores

Summary#

Bill 50, the Supporting Wine Jobs and Growth in the Niagara Region Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Alcohol and Gaming Regulation and Public Protection Act, 1996. Its stated goal is to support wine jobs and growth; its main change is to exempt certain wine purchases from the tax set out in that Act.

  • The tax would not apply to purchases of Vintners Quality Alliance (VQA) wine or Ontario wine from a winery retail store located at a winery.
  • The exception would not cover Ontario wine produced with concentrated juice from apples grown outside Ontario.
  • The bill does not limit the exception to Niagara wineries in its operative wording, despite the title.
  • The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not say whether it passed or received Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People buying wine: The specified tax would not apply to eligible purchases made at a winery retail store located at a winery. The bill does not require a store to lower its price by the amount of the tax.
  • Wineries: The tax exception would apply to qualifying purchases at their winery retail stores. The bill does not require wineries to take any other action or create a grant or jobs program.
  • Other wine purchases: The exception is limited to the stated wine types and retail location. It does not exempt all Ontario wine or purchases from other kinds of stores.

Money#

No estimate of public revenue loss or implementation cost is provided.

  • The exception could reduce revenue from the tax on eligible purchases; the amount is unknown.
  • The bill does not set a tax rate or specify a price reduction for customers.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Act is not supplied, so the current scope and rate of the tax in subsection 27(1) could not be checked.
  • The bill does not define “Vintners Quality Alliance wine,” “Ontario wine,” or “winery retail store.” Their meanings may depend on other law, which was not supplied.
  • The bill does not explain how the exception would be applied at purchase or how eligibility would be checked.
  • It is unclear how much eligible wine is sold through these stores, and therefore how much tax revenue might be affected.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to support Ontario’s wine sector by removing a tax on specified wine purchases at winery retail stores.
  • Targeting qualifying VQA and Ontario wine, while excluding Ontario wine made with concentrated juice from out-of-province apples, could focus the exception on certain products tied to Ontario.
  • The title identifies Niagara, but the rule is not limited to that region; the exception could apply more broadly.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill would reduce tax revenue without stating the likely amount or how the cost would be accounted for.
  • The exception covers only specified wine purchases at winery retail stores, so it does not provide the same tax treatment for all Ontario wine purchases.
  • The bill does not ensure that customers pay lower prices or that the exception creates or protects jobs.