Maple wine sales at farmers markets

Summary#

Bill 184, the Liquor Licence Amendment Act (Maple Wine and Mead), 2017, would amend Ontario’s Liquor Licence Act. Its stated goal is to set conditions for selling maple wine or mead at farmers’ markets; it would not itself grant permission to sell there.

  • A manufacturer that makes maple wine or mead could sell it at a farmers’ market only if the Registrar authorizes an occasional extension of a winery retail store that the manufacturer owns and operates at its production site.
  • The manufacturer must follow the Registrar’s authorization, give advance notice of the location and dates, and return unsold products to its store within 24 hours of leaving it.
  • The sale can proceed only if the municipality, if any, where the market is located has not told the Registrar in writing that it objects.
  • The manufacturer must follow the Registrar’s sampling guidelines. Anyone involved in selling or sampling liquor must hold a certificate for a Board-approved server training course.
  • The bill would not authorize markets where all, or a substantial number, of the products offered for sale are maple wine or mead. It would take effect on Royal Assent if passed.

What it means for you#

  • Manufacturers: The bill would set conditions for an authorized market sale. It would not guarantee authorization or create a process for applying.
  • Farmers’ markets: A market would have to meet the bill’s definition of a farmers’ market. The bill would not authorize a market mainly devoted to selling maple wine or mead.
  • Customers: You might encounter these products for sale at a market if the Registrar authorizes the extension and the other conditions are met. The bill does not require any market to offer them.
  • Current law: The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not verify how the authorization or liquor-sale rules work under current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost or compliance costs.

  • The bill does not set out public funding, a tax, a fee, or a fine.
  • Manufacturers would have to meet the notice, product-return, sampling, and training conditions, but the materials give no cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • “Maple wine” and “mead” would have the meanings set out in regulations, but those definitions are not included in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not set out the authorization process, decision criteria, or timeline. It also does not say how far in advance manufacturers must give notice.
  • “Occasional extension” and “substantial number” are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not explain how the new conditions fit with other rules for winery retail stores or farmers’ markets.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let eligible manufacturers offer maple wine or mead at farmers’ markets while setting limits on where and how sales happen.
  • Requiring municipal non-objection, trained sellers and samplers, and the return of unsold stock could be seen as safeguards around those sales.
  • The bill would keep farmers’ markets from becoming markets where maple wine or mead makes up all or a substantial number of the products offered.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a manufacturer’s ability to sell would depend on Registrar authorization and, where there is a municipality, the absence of a written objection. The bill does not explain the authorization criteria or process.
  • The notice, training, sampling, and product-return requirements may add work or costs for manufacturers; the materials do not estimate them.
  • The meaning of “occasional” and “substantial number” could affect which sales or markets qualify, but the bill does not define those terms.