Wine tax exemption boosts wineries

Summary#

Bill 209, the Supporting Economic Recovery and Renewal in the Niagara Region Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Alcohol, Cannabis and Gaming Regulation and Public Protection Act, 1996. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, is to support economic recovery and renewal in Niagara; the bill does this by exempting some wine purchases from a tax.

  • The exemption would apply to purchases from a winery retail store located at a winery.
  • The wine must be either Vintners Quality Alliance (VQA) wine or made entirely from grapes grown in Ontario.
  • The bill does not limit the exemption to Niagara wineries: it applies to qualifying purchases at winery retail stores wherever they are in Ontario.
  • The exemption would start when the Act receives Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Wine buyers: You would not pay the basic tax on a qualifying wine purchase at a winery retail store located at a winery. The bill does not exempt other wine purchases or say that other taxes or charges are removed.
  • Wineries: A winery with qualifying wine sold through a retail store at the winery would be affected by the tax exemption. The bill does not require wineries to lower the wine’s price.
  • Other sellers and purchases: The exemption is tied to where the wine is bought. It would not apply under this bill to a purchase from a store that is not a winery retail store located at a winery.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is provided in the available material.

  • Ontario would forgo the basic tax on eligible purchases. No publicly available information gives the amount.
  • The bill does not set a fee, provide funding, or state an amount wineries must spend.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “VQA wine” or explain how a seller confirms that wine qualifies.
  • It does not set out record-keeping, enforcement, or other procedures for applying the exemption.
  • No publicly available information gives the tax rate or the likely number or value of eligible purchases.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the current tax rules and how this exception fits with them could not be checked.
  • The bill says the exemption starts on Royal Assent, but the available material does not say whether or when that occurred.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to support winery sales by removing the basic tax from certain purchases made at winery retail stores.
  • A possible argument for the exemption is that it favours VQA wine and wine made entirely from Ontario-grown grapes.
  • The rule is limited to specified wines and a specified place of purchase, rather than removing the basic tax on all wine.

Case against#

  • The bill does not show how much the exemption would cost in lost tax revenue or how many purchases would qualify.
  • The place-of-purchase condition means qualifying wine bought elsewhere would not receive this exemption.
  • The bill does not explain how eligibility would be checked or what happens if a seller applies the exemption incorrectly.