Memorial Cross Plates for Recipients

Summary#

Bill 68, the Highway Traffic Amendment Act (Memorial Cross Number Plates), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to show respect for the sacrifice of people who received the Memorial Cross.

  • The Ministry would have to issue Memorial Cross number plates to an eligible recipient who applies under rules set by regulation.
  • A recipient without an eligible vehicle could apply for a souvenir Memorial Cross plate.
  • A recipient could receive plates for one eligible vehicle. The bill excludes certain vehicles, including motorcycles and commercial vehicles over 5,500 kilograms; regulations could exclude other prescribed vehicles.
  • The bill would bar a fee from being prescribed for these plates under the Act’s fee-setting power. The plates could not have a number requested by the recipient.

What it means for you#

  • Memorial Cross recipients: If you meet the bill’s eligibility rules and apply as required by regulation, the Ministry would have to issue plates for one eligible vehicle. The bill defines a recipient as someone granted the Memorial Cross by the Government of Canada.
  • Recipients without an eligible vehicle: You could apply for a souvenir plate under the regulations.
  • Vehicle owners and lessees: The bill does not make every vehicle eligible. It excludes specified vehicle types and allows regulations to prescribe further exclusions.
  • Other Ontarians: The bill does not change who may receive the Memorial Cross, or create a compensation payment or other benefit.

Money#

No publicly available information on implementation costs appears in the supplied material.

  • The bill bars a fee from being prescribed for Memorial Cross plates under the Act’s fee-setting power.
  • It gives no estimate for the cost of producing or issuing plates or souvenirs, or for Ministry staff and administration.

What is unclear#

  • The Highway Traffic Act itself was not supplied, so the current plate rules and what would change from them could not be verified.
  • The bill requires applications to follow regulations, but those regulations are not included. Application steps and any other conditions are therefore unclear.
  • Regulations could exclude additional vehicles, but the bill does not name them.
  • The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed or received Royal Assent. It would start on Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to recognize the sacrifice associated with the Memorial Cross through a visible plate.
  • Requiring the Ministry to issue plates to recipients who meet the conditions would provide a clear legal entitlement, rather than leaving issuance optional.
  • The souvenir plate option would let recipients apply even if they do not have an eligible vehicle.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set out the application process or all eligibility details; these depend on regulations not supplied here.
  • Some recipients may not qualify for vehicle plates because of the vehicle exclusions, and the bill does not explain why those categories were chosen.
  • The bill creates a duty for the Ministry but provides no estimate of the cost or staffing needed to carry it out.