Deceased Donor Recognition Bill

Summary#

Bill 237, the Robbie’s Legacy Act (Honouring Beloved Organ and Tissue Donors), 2024, would amend Ontario’s Gift of Life Act. Its goal is to allow hospitals to publicly recognize deceased organ and tissue donors while limiting what information is disclosed and requiring consent.

  • It would create an exception to the Act’s disclosure restriction: a deceased donor’s name may be made public as recognition of their donation if the bill’s conditions are met.
  • The hospital would choose the form of recognition, such as a memorial or another form it considers appropriate to show appreciation.
  • Only the donor’s name could be used to identify them; no additional identifying information, including the transplant date, could be made public.
  • At least six months must have passed since the transplant, and consent must be obtained for public identification and the specific way it will be done.

What it means for you#

  • Hospitals: A hospital may publicly recognize a deceased donor if all the conditions are met. The bill does not require a hospital to do so.
  • Deceased donors and their substitutes: Public recognition would require consent. If the donor personally consented to donation, consent to public identification must come from the person who would be the donor’s substitute under the Act when that approval is sought. If a substitute consented to donation, that same substitute must approve public identification.
  • The public: A donor’s name could be shared, but not additional identifying information such as the transplant date under this exception.
  • Donation consent: The bill concerns public recognition after death. It does not change the consent rules for donation itself.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.

  • The bill does not set out funding, staffing, or a cost estimate for hospitals.

What is unclear#

  • The Gift of Life Act was not supplied, so the full current disclosure rules and how this exception fits with them could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set out a process, timeline, or review for deciding whether to offer public recognition.
  • The six-month condition refers to a transplant for which consent was given under the provision for a person’s own consent. It is unclear how that wording applies when a substitute gave the donation consent.
  • The bill does not specify how hospitals would pay for or organize memorials or other forms of recognition.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let hospitals recognize donors while keeping disclosure limited to the donor’s name.
  • Requiring consent to the specific form of public recognition gives the relevant substitute a say over how the donor is identified.
  • The six-month wait means recognition would not happen immediately after the transplant.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a donor’s name is still personal information, and making it public may not be wanted by the donor’s substitute.
  • The bill does not require hospitals to use a consistent process or to offer recognition, so whether a donor is recognized could depend on the hospital.
  • It is unclear how the six-month condition applies when a substitute gave the original donation consent.