Rack Mounts Might Obscure Licence Plate

Summary#

Bill 65, the No Flak for Carrying Racks Act (Highway Traffic Amendment), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. It would create a limited exception for a rear carrying rack that obscures a vehicle’s number plate, if the rack is mounted according to requirements set by regulation. The bill’s stated goal is to “end flak” for carrying racks.

  • Drivers could drive on a highway even if a qualifying rack obscures the rear number plate, but only if the rack is mounted according to the regulations.
  • The bill defines carrying racks to include bicycle, luggage and ski racks; wheelchair carriers and lifts; trailer hitches; and similar carrying devices.
  • The bill authorizes regulations to set mounting requirements. It does not set those requirements itself.
  • I cannot verify from the supplied material what the current Act or regulations require about obscured plates.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers using carrying racks: If the bill became law and the rack met the regulatory requirements, you could drive on a highway even if it obscured the rear number plate. The exception would not cover a rack that failed to meet those requirements.
  • Other drivers and the public: The bill does not directly change other driving rules or create a new service. It does not say that drivers must use a rack or that they must apply for permission.
  • Current-law comparison: The parent Act and regulations were not supplied, so I could not verify how this exception would change existing rules in practice.

Money#

No cost information is provided in the supplied material.

  • The bill authorizes regulations setting mounting requirements, but gives no cost estimate for making or enforcing them.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material gives an estimate of costs to government, drivers or businesses.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say what the mounting requirements would be; those would be set by regulation.
  • It does not say when those regulations would be made. It says the Act would start on Royal Assent.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether Bill 65 became law. No publicly available information in the supplied material confirms its status.
  • The parent Act and current regulations were not supplied, so their existing plate rules and any overlap with this exception could not be verified.

Case for#

  • A carrying rack can obscure a rear number plate. A possible argument for the bill is that a driver should not be barred from driving solely because a rack mounted according to the rules blocks the plate.
  • Requiring racks to meet regulatory mounting requirements could allow an exception while still setting conditions for how racks are mounted.

Case against#

  • A plate obscured by a rack may be harder to see. The bill does not explain whether the regulations would require another way to display the plate.
  • The bill leaves the key mounting requirements to future regulations, so the practical scope of the exception is not clear from the bill alone.
  • Without the current Act and regulations, it is unclear how much the bill would change existing rules or how drivers would know whether a rack qualifies.