Summary#
Bill 109, Jennifer’s Law (Retail Sales Tax Amendment Act Respecting HST Rebates for Medical Supplies), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Retail Sales Tax Act by adding a rebate mechanism for the Ontario portion of HST on certain medical supplies. Its stated goal is to provide rebates, but the bill does not guarantee that a buyer will receive one.
- A supplier may pay or credit the buyer all or part of the Ontario HST on a listed supply, on behalf of Ontario.
- If the supplier does not pay or credit an amount, the buyer may apply to the federal Minister of National Revenue. The Minister may pay or credit an amount on Ontario’s behalf.
- The listed supplies are qualifying wigs, saliva substitute and artificial saliva, wound-care supplies, and batteries for medical supplies. Regulations may add other supplies.
- A wig qualifies only for someone with abnormal hair loss due to disease, medical treatment or accident, and with a medical prescription.
- The rebate section would apply only if Ontario and Canada amend their tax coordination agreement to allow the payments and credits.
What it means for you#
- Buyers of listed medical supplies: If the agreement is amended, you may be able to get some or all of the Ontario HST paid or credited. The bill does not require suppliers to offer the point-of-sale rebate, or require the federal minister to pay an application.
- Suppliers: You may provide a rebate at the point of sale on Ontario’s behalf. The bill does not require you to do so.
- Ontario and the federal government: The bill authorizes payments or credits on Ontario’s behalf. It does not create a new agency or a guaranteed front-line service.
- Other taxpayers: The bill does not change the HST rate. It creates a possible rebate of the Ontario portion for specified supplies.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- Rebate payments or credits would be made on behalf of Ontario, but the bill does not state how much they would cost.
- The bill requires no supplier to offer rebates, and it sets no staffing or administration budget.
- No information is given about possible later savings or returns.
What is unclear#
- The Retail Sales Tax Act and the agreement it refers to were not supplied, so the existing rebate rules and the agreement’s terms could not be checked against current law.
- The bill does not say when, or whether, Ontario and Canada will amend the agreement. The rebate provisions cannot apply before that change.
- The bill does not set application steps, deadlines, proof requirements, review rights or payment timelines.
- The bill does not explain how much of the tax a supplier should rebate, beyond allowing all or part of it, or how the federal minister would determine an amount.
- “Batteries for medical supplies” is not defined. The bill leaves other eligible supplies to future regulations.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it could reduce the Ontario HST cost of certain medical supplies for buyers.
- Allowing a supplier to provide a rebate at the point of sale could give buyers relief without requiring them to pay the full tax first.
- The bill also provides a possible route to apply to the federal minister if a supplier does not provide a rebate.
Case against#
- The bill does not guarantee a rebate: suppliers may choose not to provide one, and the federal minister may choose not to pay an application.
- The measure depends on a future change to the Ontario-Canada agreement, with no timing set in the bill.
- The eligible list is limited, and regulations would determine whether other medical supplies qualify.
- The bill leaves important application, payment and review details to later rules or does not address them.