Summary#
Bill 93, Gasoline Tax Fairness for All Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act. Its stated goal is to match a municipal rebate for transit or public transportation with a rebate for another municipality’s highways, when the Legislature authorizes the highway payment.
- If the Minister agrees to give one municipality a gasoline-tax rebate for transit or public transportation, the Minister must not refuse an agreement to give another municipality a rebate for work on highways under that municipality’s jurisdiction—if the Legislature has authorized payment by appropriation.
- Eligible highway purposes listed in the bill are planning, designing, constructing, maintaining, managing or operating highways.
- The second municipality’s rebate would be calculated using its population and highway distance relative to those of the first municipality, multiplied by the first municipality’s rebate.
- The bill does not itself appropriate money or change the gasoline tax rate.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities: A municipality could receive a highway rebate under the bill’s formula if another municipality receives a rebate for transit or public transportation and the Legislature authorizes the highway payment. The Minister must not refuse to enter the agreement if those conditions apply.
- Municipal residents and road users: The bill does not directly change your taxes, create a personal benefit, or require a municipality to undertake any listed highway work.
- Taxpayers: Public money could be used for the rebates, but the bill makes the highway payment conditional on a legislative appropriation.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material; the highway rebate depends on the Legislature authorizing payment by appropriation.
- The rebate amount would depend on the first municipality’s rebate and the relative populations and highway distances of the two municipalities.
- The bill does not set aside money, specify a total spending limit, or change the gasoline tax rate.
What is unclear#
- The Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act is not supplied, so the existing ministerial powers and how the bill would fit with current law could not be verified.
- The bill does not explain how or when the Legislature would decide whether to authorize an appropriation.
- It does not specify how population or highway distance would be measured, or when those figures would be updated.
- It is unclear how the formula would work if more than one municipality receives a transit or public-transportation rebate.
- The bill does not set out an application process, decision timeline, or appeal process.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to provide a highway rebate when the Minister agrees to a transit or public-transportation rebate for another municipality.
- A possible argument for the formula is that it accounts for both population and the length of roads under municipal jurisdiction.
- Requiring legislative authorization for payment means the bill does not itself commit public money.
Case against#
- The bill does not set a spending cap or explain how appropriations would be decided, so the total public cost is unclear.
- The formula is tied to the first municipality’s rebate, as well as relative population and highway distance; it does not state that other factors, such as a municipality’s highway needs, affect the amount.
- The bill does not explain which first municipality would be used if more than one receives a transit or public-transportation rebate.