Summary#
Bill 14, the Zebra Mussel Analysis Act, 2018, would create a separate Act; it does not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation into the extent of the zebra mussel problem in 35 named waterways. Its stated goal is to determine zebra mussel content in those waterways.
- The minister must direct the investigation under subsection 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act.
- The named waterways are Cana Lake, Canal Bay, Canal Lake, Canard Lake, Canard River, Canary Lake, Cancer Lake, Candide Creek, Candide Lake, Candler Lake, Candybar Creek, Candybar Lake, Candy Creek, Cane Lake, Canisbay Creek, Canisbay Lake, Canis Lake, Canister Creek, Canister Lake, Can Lake, Canna Creek, Canna Lake, Cannard's Bay, Canniff Creek, Canniff Lake, Canning Lake, Cannings Falls, Cannon Creek, Cannon Lake, Canoe Bay, Canoe Bay Channel, Canoe Channel, Canoe Creek and Canoe Lake.
- The Act would start on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People who live near or use the named waterways: The minister would have to direct an investigation into the zebra mussel problem there. The bill does not require any particular response to the findings.
- People using other waterways: The bill names no other waterways for investigation.
- Everyone: The bill does not create a mussel-control or removal program, a public reporting requirement, new fees, or rules requiring people to test or report mussels.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill requires the minister to direct an investigation but gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
- It does not specify staffing, testing methods, or who would carry out the investigation.
What is unclear#
- The Ontario Water Resources Act was not supplied, so its current requirements under subsection 15(1) could not be checked against this bill’s description.
- The bill sets no deadline and does not say what the investigation must involve or how its findings must be reported.
- It does not define how to measure the “extent” of the problem or say whether the results must be made public.
- It does not explain how the investigation would be funded or staffed.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to require investigation of zebra mussels in a specific set of waterways.
- A possible argument for the bill is that directing an investigation could give the minister information about the problem in those named waters.
- Naming the waterways makes the required scope more specific than a general call to study zebra mussels.
Case against#
- The bill does not set a deadline, method, or reporting requirement, so it is unclear what information the investigation must produce or when.
- It requires an investigation but does not require action to control zebra mussels if they are found.
- The bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan, making the resources needed unclear.