Summary#
Bill 20, the Waterways Analysis Act, 2018, is a proposed standalone law; it does not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation into zebra mussels in listed waterways. Its stated goal is to determine how much zebra mussel content is present there.
- The minister must direct the investigation under a responsibility in section 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act. The bill’s explanatory note says that responsibility already exists, but the Act itself was not supplied, so its current scope could not be checked.
- The investigation would cover these named places: Grant Point Harbour, Grants Creek, Grants Creek Bay, Gosselin Creek, Gosselin Lake, Gosselin's Bay, Goss Lake, Goudreau Creek, Goudreau Lake, Goudy Creek, Goudy Lake, Gough Creek, Gough Lake, Gouinlock Lake, Gouin Lake, Goulais Bay, Goulais Lake, Goulais River, Gould Creek, Goulding Lake, Goulet Bay, Goulet Creek, Goulet Lake, Gourd Lake, Gourlay Lake, Gourlie Creek, Govan Lake, Gove Lake, Gover Lake, Government Bay, Government Creek, Government Lake, Governor Bay, Gowan Creek, Gowan Lake, Gowar Bay, Goward Lake, Gowganda Bay, Gowganda Lake, Gowie Bay, Grabers Lake, Grab Lake, Grace Bay, Grace Creek, Graceful Lake, Grace Lake, Gracie Lake, Grady Lake, Graff Lake, Goose Lake, Goose Neck Bay, Gooseneck Creek, Gooseneck Lake, Gooseneck Rapids, Goose Pond, Goose River, Gord Lake, Gordon Bay, Gordon Creek, Gordon Lake, Gordon Rapids, Gordons Bay and Gordons Creek.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. It does not require cleanup or other action based on the investigation.
What it means for you#
- Environment minister and ministry: The minister would have a legal duty to direct the investigation. The bill does not say who must carry it out or set a deadline.
- People who live near or use the listed waterways: The bill requires an investigation but does not require public access to results, set out how the investigation would be done, or promise any follow-up action.
- People and businesses generally: The bill does not create a new individual duty, fee, fine, benefit, or restriction.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires an investigation but gives no budget estimate or funding source.
- It does not state how many staff or how much expertise the work would require.
What is unclear#
- What methods, standards, or timeline would govern the investigation?
- Would results be published, and would anyone be required to respond to them?
- How would the investigation be funded and staffed?
- The Ontario Water Resources Act was not supplied, so its existing duty and how this bill relates to it could not be verified.
- The supplied material does not say whether the bill became law.
Case for#
- The bill would require an investigation of zebra mussels in the specific waterways it names, rather than leaving that work to discretion.
- A possible argument for the bill is that investigating the extent of the problem could give the minister information about those waterways.
- The bill ties the investigation to a responsibility under the Ontario Water Resources Act, which its explanatory note says the minister already has.
Case against#
- The bill does not set methods, deadlines, reporting requirements, or follow-up duties, so the investigation’s scope and practical results are uncertain.
- It requires the minister to direct an investigation but provides no cost estimate or funding plan.
- The bill names many waterways but does not explain why these were selected or whether other waterways are covered by existing work.