Summary#
Bill 15, the Zebra Mussel Count Act, 2018, would create a separate Act, not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation under that Act into zebra mussels in named waterways. The bill’s stated goal is to determine the zebra mussel content of those waterways.
- The Minister must direct the investigation; the bill does not set out how it must be done or require a particular finding.
- The Schedule names: Carcass Lake, Card Bay, Carder Lake, Cardiff Creek, Cardiff Lake, Cardinal Creek, Cardinalis Lake, Cardinal Lake, Card Lake, Cards Lake, Cardwell Lake, Carew Lake, Carey Creek, Carey Lake, Carfrae Lake, Cargill Lake, Cargill Mill Pond, Carhess Creek, Cariad Lake, Carib Creek, Carib Lake, Cariboo Creek, Cariboo Lake, Caribou Bay, Caribou Creek, Caribou Lake, Caribou Rapids, Caribou River, Caribou Throat Lake, Caribus Lake, Carillon Rapids, Carkner Lake, Car Lake, Carl Bay, Carlbom Lake, Carl Creek, Carleton Lake, Carling Bay, Carling Lake, Carl Lake, Carlo Lake, Carlson Lake, Carlstead Bay, Carlton Lake, Carlyle Lake, Carman Bay, Carman Creek, Carman Lake, Carrnichael Lake, Carnachan Bay, Carnahan Lake, Carney Creek and Carnilac Lake.
- The bill says it would come into force when it receives Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Minister and ministry: The Minister would have a legal duty to direct an investigation of the listed waterways.
- People who use or live near those waterways: The bill does not require you to apply, provide information, pay a fee or change how you use the water. It does not create a public reporting service or require findings to be published.
- General public: The bill does not create a new right, ban, fine or benefit.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill gives no cost estimate or specific funding amount. It requires an investigation but does not say how it would be staffed or paid for.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set a deadline, method, scope or standard for the investigation.
- It does not say whether the Minister must publish results or take further action based on them.
- “Extent of the zebra mussel problem” is not defined.
- The Ontario Water Resources Act is not supplied, so I could not verify what subsection 15(1) already requires or how the bill’s duty would interact with it.
Case for#
- A required investigation could give the Minister information about zebra mussels in the specifically named waterways.
- A possible argument for the bill is that naming waterways makes clear which locations the investigation must cover, rather than leaving the choice entirely to the Minister.
- The bill directs an investigation, not a specific control measure; it does not itself impose new restrictions on waterway users.
Case against#
- The bill does not say how soon the investigation must happen, what it must measure or whether the results must be made public.
- Without a defined method or required report, the public may not know what the investigation found or how it assessed the problem.
- The bill requires an investigation but gives no funding or staffing details, so its cost and practical scope are unclear.