Summary#
Bill 25, Zebra Mussel Report Act, 2018, would create a standalone Ontario Act; it does not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation under that Act’s subsection 15(1). Its stated goal is to determine the extent of the zebra mussel problem in the named waterways.
- The investigation would cover Graveyard Rapids, Gravy Lake, Grawbarger Lake, Grawbarger’s Rapids, Graydarl Lake, Graydon Lake, Gray Lake, Grayling Lake, Graymud Lake, Gray Rapids, Grays Bay, Grays Creek, Grays Lake, Grayson Lake, Grayson River, Grays River, Graystone Lake, Graytrout Lake, Grazing Lake, Grazing River, Great Lake, Great Mountain Lake, Great North Bay, Great Portage Lake, Great South Bay, Grebe Lake, Greb Lake, Green Bay, Greenbough Lake, Green Bug Lake, Greenbush Lake, Green Creek, Grants Lake, Granzies Lake, Grape Lake, Graphic Creek, Graphic Lake, Graphite Lake, Grapnel Bay, Grapnel Creek, Grapnel Lake, Grasett Lake, Grass Creek, Grasser Lake, Grass Hill Lake, Grass Lake, Grassy Bay, Grassy Creek, Grassy Lake, Grassy Portage Bay, Grassy River, Gratton Creek, Gratton Lake, Grave Bay, Grave Creek and Grave Lake.
- The duty would fall on the minister. The bill does not set out a specific investigation method.
- The Act would start on the day it receives Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Minister: If the bill became law, the minister would have to direct an investigation into zebra mussels in the listed waterways.
- People who live near or use those waterways: The bill does not directly change your rights, require you to apply for anything, or require you to take action. It also does not require zebra mussels to be removed or controlled.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires the minister to direct an investigation, but gives no estimate for its cost or staffing.
- The bill does not set a fee, fine, or funding amount.
What is unclear#
- The Ontario Water Resources Act is not supplied, so the existing powers and duties in subsection 15(1), and how this bill would interact with them, could not be verified.
- The bill does not set a deadline, investigation method, or standard for deciding what counts as determining the extent of the problem.
- Despite its title, the bill does not require a report to be published or given to the Legislature.
- It does not say whether or how affected communities would be informed or involved.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that an investigation could provide information about the extent of zebra mussels in the specifically named waterways.
- Requiring the minister to direct the investigation would make that action a legal duty, rather than leaving it as an optional step.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill requires an investigation but does not require a public report, so the results might not be made available to residents.
- The bill sets no deadline or investigation standard, leaving the scope and timing unclear.
- The bill does not require any follow-up action to control zebra mussels if the investigation finds a problem.