Real Estate Services Act overhaul

Summary#

Bill 145, the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2020, was enacted as Chapter 1 of Ontario’s 2020 statutes. It amends the Real Estate and Business Brokers Act, 2002 and renames it the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002. Its stated goal is to change how real estate services are regulated; that goal is not a guaranteed result.

  • The registrar’s registration decisions must consider past financial position and conduct, and whether registration would be contrary to the public interest.
  • The registrar and appointed inspectors gain inspection and information-gathering powers. Registrants must provide information requested under the Act.
  • A discipline committee can hear cases about breaches of the Act and regulations, and can impose conditions, suspend or revoke registration, or order education, fines and costs. Appeals go to the Licence Appeal Tribunal.
  • Assessors can impose administrative penalties of up to $25,000 for prescribed breaches or breaches of registration conditions. An appeal is available, but a hearing is not always required before the initial order.
  • The Act creates a conditional exemption from registration for personal real estate corporations and prescribed members. It also restricts who may claim to be a specialist in real estate trading.
  • Brokerages must keep records of written offers to purchase, and the registrar must disclose the number of offers on request. The registrar generally cannot disclose their contents or the identity of offer-makers, except in prescribed circumstances.

What it means for you#

  • Real estate registrants and brokerages: The registrar may request information about a trade or a group of registrants, and registrants must provide it in the required form and time. Registrants must also report specified changes within five days.
  • Registrants and applicants: Registration decisions can take past conduct and finances into account, including those of certain people connected to an applicant. The registrar must be satisfied that granting or renewing registration is not contrary to the public interest.
  • Registrants who advertise a specialty: You cannot hold yourself out as a specialist unless the area is established under regulations and you meet the education, certification and other requirements set under those regulations.
  • Brokerages and their staff: Inspectors may enter and inspect business premises at a reasonable time without a warrant, but not a part used as a dwelling. They may examine or demand relevant records and other things, and ask about relevant financial matters. Inspectors cannot use force to enter.
  • Real estate buyers and sellers: If you ask the registrar about offers received on a property, the registrar must disclose the number as soon as practicable or within a prescribed time. The bill generally protects the contents of offers and the identity of offer-makers from disclosure.
  • Personal real estate corporations: The bill provides a registration exemption, but only subject to conditions set by regulations. It does not set out those conditions in the bill text.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill allows inspectors and assessors to be appointed, but gives no staffing numbers or cost estimate.
  • Administrative penalties can be up to $25,000. Discipline committee fines can be up to $50,000 for a broker or salesperson and $100,000 for a brokerage. Penalties and fines are payable to the administrative authority or, if there is none, the Minister of Finance.
  • The bill does not state expected revenue, public savings, or costs to brokerages and registrants.

What is unclear#

  • The Act says it starts on a day set by proclamation, but the supplied material does not give that date.
  • The bill relies on regulations for key details, including conditions for the personal-corporation exemption, which breaches can bring administrative penalties, and specialist certification rules.
  • The bill does not set out the full procedures for inspections, discipline cases or administrative-penalty orders. It allows regulations to govern some of those procedures.
  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act or a current consolidated version. I could not verify which changes have taken effect or how they interact with current law.
  • The bill does not explain how the registrar’s expanded powers will be staffed or funded.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to strengthen oversight of real estate registrants and protect the public by making registration decisions account for past conduct and financial position.
  • Giving the discipline committee authority over breaches of the Act and regulations, not only the code of ethics, could allow more kinds of misconduct to be addressed through discipline.
  • Administrative penalties provide another way to promote compliance and prevent people from keeping economic benefits from violations.
  • Requiring disclosure of the number of offers while generally protecting their contents and authors’ identities could give requesters limited information without routinely exposing offer details.

Case against#

  • The registrar’s expanded role, including assessing penalties and requesting information, comes with few process details in the bill itself; some are left to regulations.
  • An administrative penalty can be imposed without a hearing beforehand, and it applies even if the person took reasonable steps to prevent the breach or honestly believed mistaken facts. The person can appeal within 15 days after receiving the order.
  • Registration decisions can consider the past conduct and financial position of applicants and connected people. The bill does not explain how those matters will be weighed in practice.
  • The bill authorizes new inspection and enforcement work but provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2020022701

    Passed91 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 145

    FOR · 91

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    91For

    • PC61
    • NDP29
    • Green1

    0Against