Summary#
Bill 139, the Less Red Tape, More Common Sense Act, 2023, was enacted as Chapter 20 of Ontario’s 2023 statutes. It amends 20 existing Acts; it does not create one new operating program. Its stated goal is to reduce red tape, but the amendments do not guarantee that result.
- Niagara Escarpment enforcement officers gain inspection powers, including powers to require relevant documents and information and take samples or photographs. Some violations and obstruction can lead to fines of up to $10,000.
- Municipal councils must consent, without conditions, to certain heritage-building alterations required for religious practices if the bill’s conditions are met. This includes Indigenous religious or spiritual practices.
- The minimum fine for a conviction under a specified offence in the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act, 2002 rises from $2,500 to $5,000.
- For rules proposed under three financial-regulation Acts, the minimum written-comment period falls from 90 days to 60 days. A separate public-consultation condition for certain retirement-home regulations is repealed.
- Five universities can make an exception to the six-year board-member limit for a member serving as chair, subject to limits. The French-language university also gets an exception for certain senior appointments.
- Other changes affect charities’ notice requirements, agricultural societies’ financial reporting, credit-union transactions, professional-engineer processes, and land easements granted by the St. Lawrence Parks Commission.
What it means for you#
- People and property owners in the Niagara Escarpment Planning Area: Enforcement officers may inspect land when the legal grounds for inspection are met. They may enter land without consent or a warrant, but need consent or a warrant to enter a building or dwelling. They may require relevant documents or information and conduct tests or take samples and photographs. Knowingly providing false information or obstructing an officer is an offence punishable by a fine of up to $10,000; obstructing an inspection is also punishable by a fine of up to $10,000. The Act also allows a stop-work order when development is unlawful and creates a risk to public safety or significant environmental damage.
- People seeking heritage-building changes for religious practices: A council must approve qualifying alterations without conditions. The applicant must provide a sworn affidavit or declaration and required information. The council must rely exclusively on that affidavit or declaration to show the stated conditions are met. If the council misses certain notice deadlines, consent may be deemed given.
- Motor vehicle dealers: The minimum fine for conviction under the specified offence rises to $5,000. The bill also repeals two other provisions of that Act, but the supplied material does not explain their effects.
- Charity executors and trustees: The required written notice about property given for a religious, educational, charitable or public purpose goes to the beneficiary or person named to receive the gift, rather than the Public Guardian and Trustee. Corporations established for those purposes do not have to include a copy of their incorporation document with the notice.
- Financial regulators and people or companies commenting on proposed rules: The minimum comment period is shorter, at 60 days instead of 90. This applies to rules under the Commodity Futures Act, Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario Act, 2016 and Securities Act.
- Other affected groups: Agricultural and horticultural societies will use financial information set by regulation instead of audited financial statements for the specified reporting requirements; some of these changes need proclamation to start. Credit unions may accept a member’s deposit in trust for a named beneficiary, and a restriction on using membership or patronage shares in certain transactions between credit unions is removed. The St. Lawrence Parks Commission may grant an easement over land without approval from the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
- University board members and professional engineers: The bill changes board-term limits at five universities and changes some professional-engineer forms, document-delivery and investigation processes. It does not create a new university or regulator.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill authorizes expanded inspection and enforcement powers but gives no estimate for staffing or enforcement costs.
- The specified motor-vehicle-dealer fine increases, and the new Niagara Escarpment offences carry fines of up to $10,000.
- The material does not estimate costs for societies, universities, credit unions or other affected organizations.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves some details to regulations, including the financial information agricultural and horticultural societies must provide and requirements for heritage-alteration applications.
- Some provisions start only on proclamation, including the specified agricultural reporting changes, the changes to the Modernizing Ontario for People and Businesses Act, 2020, and the heritage-alteration rules. The supplied material does not say whether proclamation has since occurred: No publicly available information.
- The supplied material does not explain the practical effects of repealing sections of the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act, 2002 or provisions of the Restoring Ontario’s Competitiveness Act, 2019.
- The supplied material does not set out all the grounds and limits for Niagara Escarpment inspections, or explain how the new enforcement powers will be overseen.
- The supplied material does not explain how the reduced comment periods or repeal of the retirement-home consultation condition will affect specific future rules.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that shorter minimum comment periods and online notices could reduce delay and make some processes simpler.
- Allowing certain university board chairs to serve longer could help boards keep experienced chairs in place, while the bill still sets maximum service limits.
- The Niagara Escarpment changes set out inspection powers and limits, including the need for consent or a warrant to enter a building or dwelling.
- The heritage rules create a clear route for alterations needed for religious practices, including Indigenous practices.
Case against#
- Shorter comment periods may give the public and affected businesses less time to respond to proposed financial rules.
- A council must approve qualifying heritage alterations without conditions and may be deemed to have consented if it misses deadlines. The council must rely exclusively on the applicant’s affidavit or declaration for the listed conditions.
- Expanded inspection powers could burden property owners and other people subject to inspection; the bill does not describe a detailed complaint or review process in the supplied material.
- Longer board service and the repeal of a retirement-home consultation condition may reduce opportunities for board turnover or public input. The supplied material does not explain what other safeguards apply.