Party elections transparency bill proposed

Summary#

Bill 150 would create the Ensuring Transparency and Integrity in Political Party Elections Act, 2019 and amend Ontario’s Election Finances Act. Its stated goal is to set rules for certain elections within registered political parties; it would start on Royal Assent if enacted.

  • Party leaders or party chief financial officers must report results of candidate nominations, leadership elections and party-president elections to Ontario’s Chief Electoral Officer within seven days. The reports include eligible-voter and turnout numbers, candidates’ vote totals, and contestants’ names and addresses.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer must share relevant reported information with contestants and publish the report information online. Parties must also promptly report the names of people appointed to those positions.
  • A candidate in one of these elections may challenge its validity in the Superior Court of Justice within 30 days. The candidate must provide $2,000 security toward possible court costs.
  • The bill creates offences for specified election misconduct, including voting when ineligible or more than once, ballot interference, giving false or misleading information to an election official, inducing an unqualified person to vote, and wilfully miscounting ballots. Fines and, for some offences, imprisonment can apply.
  • It repeals three nomination-contest reporting provisions in the Election Finances Act. The bill’s explanatory note says those reporting requirements are re-enacted in this new Act.

What it means for you#

  • Registered parties and their leaders or chief financial officers: They would have to file the required reports on time and report appointments promptly. A leader or chief financial officer who knowingly fails to meet the reporting rules could face a fine of up to $5,000. The party could face $50 for each day the default continues.
  • People running in party elections: Their names and addresses, and reported election results, would be published online. A candidate could ask the Superior Court to decide whether an election was valid, subject to the 30-day deadline and security requirement.
  • People taking part in party elections: The bill would make certain voting and ballot-related conduct offences. For some offences, a judge who finds the conduct was knowing could impose a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment for up to two years less a day, or both.
  • Chief Electoral Officer: The office would have to receive reports, share information with contestants and publish notices online.
  • General public: These rules concern registered political parties’ internal elections and selection of official candidates. The bill does not directly change how voters cast ballots in a provincial general election.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns reporting and publication duties to parties and the Chief Electoral Officer, but gives no estimate for staffing or other costs.
  • It sets fines, including a party fine of $50 for each day a knowing reporting default continues. Fines are penalties, not stated as a source of program funding.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Election Finances Act is not supplied, so I could not verify the existing reporting rules or how the bill’s changes compare with current law.
  • The bill relies on terms from that Act, and its text does not define every term used in the rules.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer must use forms that the officer prescribes, but the bill does not say what those forms will require beyond the listed report information.
  • The bill does not set out detailed procedures for investigating offences or explain the legal grounds and process for a court challenge beyond its deadline and security requirement.
  • It does not explain how the public information will be protected or used, despite requiring publication of contestants’ addresses.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make the outcomes and participation levels of party elections more visible through public reporting.
  • Reporting vote totals and eligible-voter and turnout numbers could give contestants and the public a clearer record of how a party election was conducted.
  • A court process could give a candidate a formal way to challenge an election’s validity.
  • Specific offences and penalties could discourage dishonest voting, ballot interference and wilful miscounting.

Case against#

  • Publishing contestants’ addresses could expose personal information, and the bill does not describe limits on that disclosure.
  • The bill puts reporting duties on party officials and the Chief Electoral Officer without estimating the cost or explaining what resources will be provided.
  • The bill sets a $2,000 security requirement for a court challenge. That amount could be a practical barrier for some candidates; the bill does not provide an exception.
  • Some details depend on party rules, including how leadership contestants’ eligible voters are counted. The bill does not set one common eligibility rule for all parties.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2019121202

    Passed95 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 150

    FOR · 95

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    95For

    • PC60
    • NDP33
    • Green1
    • Liberal1

    0Against