Summary#
The bill’s short title in its text is the Public Accountability and Lobbyist Transparency Act, 2019; the supplied title labels it 2020. It would amend four Ontario laws: the Legislative Assembly Act, Lobbyists Registration Act, 1998, Members’ Integrity Act, 1994 and Public Service of Ontario Act, 2006. Its stated goal is greater public accountability and lobbyist transparency; it would take effect on Royal Assent.
- Lobbyists would have to give the registrar dates, times and electronic communications about lobbying. Members of the Executive Council (cabinet ministers) would have to report lobbying or meetings with lobbyists within 30 days.
- The Integrity Commissioner would have to investigate covered disclosures of wrongdoing and publish a report at the end, unless the Commissioner considers a public report not in the public interest.
- Individuals could ask the Integrity Commissioner for an opinion about a member of the Assembly’s conduct; Assembly members could ask the lobbyist registrar for an opinion about another member’s compliance with the Lobbyists Registration Act.
- The Speaker would have to notify police or federal prosecutors about certain Assembly inquiries. Those officials may investigate; reports and tabling duties apply in specified cases.
- The bill would increase certain penalties, add possible imprisonment for Lobbyists Registration Act offences, and make it contempt for the Government House Leader not to ensure the Assembly considers and responds to Integrity Commissioner reports.
What it means for you#
- Lobbyists and organizations that employ them: Consultant lobbyists, including a director or principal of such an individual, and in-house lobbyists would have to provide lobbying dates, times and electronic communications as specified. The bill makes the registrar’s register public.
- Cabinet ministers: A minister who is lobbied by, or otherwise meets with, a consultant or in-house lobbyist must report the lobbyist’s name, meeting dates and times, and subject matter within 30 days. The minister must also provide information the registrar requests to clarify the report, within 30 days.
- People reporting wrongdoing: Any individual with reason to believe wrongdoing has occurred could disclose it to the Integrity Commissioner. The bill would require the Commissioner to start an investigation, subject to an exception in the existing Act, and to make a public report unless the Commissioner considers that not in the public interest.
- Members of the Assembly and the public: Individuals could request an Integrity Commissioner opinion about a member if they have reasonable and probable grounds to believe the member breached the Act or parliamentary convention. Assembly members could similarly request a registrar opinion about another member’s alleged breach of the Lobbyists Registration Act. The Assembly could not investigate a matter referred to the registrar under the new process.
- People and institutions generally: The bill does not itself create a new public service program, a new independent agency, or a direct benefit. The Integrity Commissioner, registrar, Speaker, Assembly and named law-enforcement officials would carry out the new duties or powers.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires new reporting, investigation and public-reporting duties, but gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
- It raises certain maximum penalties. For Lobbyists Registration Act offences, the maximum would be $50,000, six months in prison, or both for a first offence; for later offences, $200,000, two years in prison, or both.
- It would also allow an additional Legislative Assembly Act penalty of up to 200% of the fee, compensation or reward involved. The bill gives no estimate of fines collected.
What is unclear#
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so the existing rules and the full scope of the changes could not be checked against current law.
- The bill does not explain how electronic communications would be protected, what information could be withheld, or how the public register would handle sensitive material.
- It does not define “wrongdoing” here or explain how the public-interest exception for publishing an investigation report would be applied.
- It does not set out timelines or detailed procedures for investigations, opinions, or how affected people could respond or challenge decisions.
- The bill adds the Ontario Provincial Police Commissioner to a list in the Public Service of Ontario Act, 2006, but the supplied text does not show the list’s function. The effect of that change is therefore unclear.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make lobbying easier to trace by recording who met whom, when, about what, and by preserving related electronic communications.
- Requiring ministers to report meetings could give the public a more direct record of contact with lobbyists.
- Requiring investigations of wrongdoing disclosures, with public reports in most cases, could make the response less dependent on discretion and more visible.
- Allowing individuals to request opinions could provide a route to raise concerns without requiring an Assembly member to do so.
Case against#
- Requiring lobbyists to provide electronic communications could create privacy, confidentiality and compliance concerns; the bill does not explain how these would be handled.
- The bill gives investigation and opinion processes new duties or powers without setting out detailed procedures, timelines or safeguards in the supplied text.
- Mandatory investigations and reporting could require significant staff time, but the bill gives no cost or staffing estimate.
- Criminal penalties, including possible imprisonment for certain reporting failures, are serious consequences; the bill does not explain how enforcement decisions would be made.