Summary#
Bill 243 would amend Ontario’s Trespass to Property Act. The supplied title identifies it as the Trespass to Property Amendment Act (Protecting Consumers from Package Piracy), 2021, but the bill text’s short-title clause says “2020.” Its stated goal is to set minimum fines for certain trespass offences involving mail.
- A person convicted of trespass under the Act would face a minimum fine if they entered premises to take, hold, conceal or destroy someone else’s mail, intending to deprive that person of the mail or defraud anyone.
- The minimum would be $500 for a first conviction, $1,000 for a second and $2,000 for each later conviction. The maximum would be $10,000 each time.
- “Mail” would include letters, packages and other sealed articles addressed to someone, as well as anything inside them.
- The bill would not create a separate offence for all package theft; it would set fines for a specified kind of existing trespass offence.
- The Act would start on a date set by proclamation. The bill does not itself set that date.
What it means for you#
- People who commit the specified trespass: If convicted, they would face the stated minimum fine, with a higher minimum for later convictions. The fine applies only where the bill’s purpose and intent conditions are met.
- People whose mail is taken: The bill would set fines for certain trespass offences involving their mail. It does not set out a process for recovering mail or getting compensation.
- Other package theft cases: The bill does not set a minimum fine for every case of missing or stolen packages. Its provisions apply to the specified trespass offence and intent.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s public costs or expected fine revenue.
- The bill sets fines of $500 to $10,000 for a first conviction, $1,000 to $10,000 for a second and $2,000 to $10,000 for each later conviction.
- It gives no estimate of how often the fines would be imposed or how much revenue they might raise.
What is unclear#
- The current text of the Trespass to Property Act was not supplied, so the existing offence’s full elements, current fines and how these changes fit with current law could not be verified.
- The bill does not explain how a court would determine that a person had the required purpose and intent.
- It does not provide details about enforcement, appeals or reporting.
- It does not say when the Act would start; that date would be set by proclamation.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address trespass involving the deliberate taking, holding, concealing or destruction of mail.
- A possible argument for the bill is that minimum fines make the financial penalty clearer and prevent fines below the stated floor for these cases.
- The increasing minimums for repeat convictions could be seen as a way to impose a stronger penalty after repeated offences.
Case against#
- One concern is that mandatory minimums limit a court’s ability to set a lower fine in an individual case.
- The bill does not explain how courts should assess the required purpose and intent, or how the new minimums would interact with existing penalties.
- It is unclear whether the minimum fines would make a practical difference, because the supplied material gives no information about current fines or how often these cases occur.