Summary#
Bill 18, the Status of Zebra Mussels Act, 2018, would create a new Act and require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation into zebra mussels in named waterways. It refers to the Ontario Water Resources Act but does not amend it in the text provided. Its stated goal is to determine the extent of the zebra mussel problem in those waterways.
- The Minister must direct an investigation under the Ontario Water Resources Act into the extent of the problem in the scheduled waterways.
- The schedule names: Catastrophe Creek, Catastrophe Lake, Catawba Lake, Cat Bay, Catchacoma Lake, Catcher Lake, Cat Creek, Caterpillar Lake, Cat Falls, Catfish Bay, Catfish Creek, Catfish Lake, Catfish Rapids, Catharine Lake, Cathro Lake, Cathy's Lake, Catlonite Creek, Catlonite Lake, Cat River, Cat Tail River, Cattral Lake, Cauchon Creek, Cauchon Lake, Caulfield Lake, Cauley Lake, Cauliflower Creek, Cauliflower Lake, Caulkin Lake, Caution Lake, Cavalary Creek, Cavalary Lake, Cavanagh Lake, Cavan Creek, Cavano Lake, Cave Harbour, Cave Lake, Cavell Creek, Cavell Lake, Cavendish Lake, Caverly's Bay, Cavern Creek, Cavern Lake, Cavers Bay, Cavers Creek, Cavers Lake, Caviar Lake, Cawanogami Lake, Cawdron Creek, Cawdron Lake, Cawing Lake, Cawston Lakes, Cawthra Creek, Caya's Lake and Cayer Creek. Cavern Creek and Cavern Lake appear twice in the schedule.
- The Act would start on Royal Assent (when it becomes law).
What it means for you#
- Minister: If the bill becomes law, the Minister must direct the investigation. The bill does not set a method, deadline or requirement to publish findings.
- People who use or live near the named waterways: The bill does not directly impose duties, fees or restrictions on you. It does not require zebra mussel removal or other action after the investigation.
- General public: The bill requires an investigation, not a new agency or a front-line service.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost of the investigation.
- The bill sets no spending amount or staffing level. Carrying out the investigation may require resources, but the bill does not estimate them.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the Ontario Water Resources Act, so its current requirements—and how this bill would relate to them—could not be verified.
- The bill does not define the investigation’s scope or method, set a deadline, or require a report to the public.
- It does not say what action, if any, must follow the findings.
- The bill does not specify funding or who would conduct the investigation.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to establish whether zebra mussels are a problem in the named waterways.
- A possible argument for the bill is that findings could give the Minister information to consider when deciding whether further action is needed.
- Requiring an investigation is narrower than requiring a particular response before the extent of the problem is known.
Case against#
- The bill does not set a deadline, method or public reporting duty, so it is unclear when or how the investigation’s findings would be delivered.
- It requires an investigation but does not require any response to its findings.
- The bill gives no cost estimate or staffing plan, leaving the resources needed unclear.