Summary#
Bill 26, the Zebra Mussel Examination Act, 2018, would create a new Act; it would not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation into the extent of the zebra mussel problem in named waterways. Its stated goal is to have the Minister determine their zebra mussel content under a responsibility the bill attributes to section 15(1) of the existing Act.
- The required investigation covers Gravel Bay, Gravel Beach Lake, Gravel Falls, Graham Bay, Graham Creek, Graham Lake, Graharns Creek, Graharn's Lake, Granary Creek, Granary Lake, Grand Bay, Grand Campment Bay, Grande Lake, Grandeur Lake, Grand Lake, Grandmaison Lake, Grandma Lake, Grandma Stevens Pond, Grandolph Bay, Grandpa Lake, Grandpop's Lake, Grand Rapids, Grand River, Grandview Lake, Granite Bay, Graniteboss Lake, Granite Creek, Granite Falls, Granitehill Lake, Granite Lake, Granite River, Granitic Lake, Granka Lake, Granny Bay, Granny's Creek, Grano Lake, Grant Bay, Grant Creek and Grant Lake.
- The Minister must direct the investigation. The bill does not say who must carry it out or set a method or deadline.
- The bill would start on the day it receives Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Minister and government: The Minister would have a legal duty to direct an investigation into the listed waterways.
- People who use or live near those waterways: The bill creates no direct duties for you and does not restrict access or use. It does not require treatment or removal of zebra mussels.
- Current law: The bill refers to a responsibility under section 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act. That Act was not supplied, so the current scope of that responsibility could not be verified.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill gives no spending amount, staffing estimate or funding source for the investigation.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set a deadline, explain the investigation method, or say who would conduct it.
- It does not define what counts as the “extent” of the zebra mussel problem.
- It does not require a report or say whether results must be made public.
- It does not say whether investigation findings must lead to any further action.
- The current requirements under section 15(1), and how this bill would interact with them, could not be checked because the parent Act was not supplied.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to obtain information about zebra mussels in the waterways it names.
- Requiring the Minister to direct an investigation could make that inquiry a legal duty rather than leaving it to the Minister’s discretion.
- Information about the named waterways could help identify the extent of the issue there, though the bill does not guarantee any particular finding or response.
Case against#
- The bill requires an investigation but sets no deadline, method, reporting requirement or follow-up action. Its practical results are therefore uncertain.
- Without a cost estimate or funding plan, the resources needed for the investigation are unknown.
- The bill does not explain why these waterways are listed or how the investigation would address zebra mussels beyond them.