Zebra Mussel Probe in Waterways Bill

Summary#

Bill 21, Zebra Mussel Study Act, 2018, would create a new Act; it would not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation under that Act into the extent of the zebra mussel problem in specifically listed waterways. The stated goal is to determine their zebra mussel content.

  • The required investigation would cover only the waterways named in the bill’s Schedule: Gore Bay, Gorge Creek, Gorge Creek Falls, Gorge Lake, Gorman Creek, Gorman Lake, Gorrnan River, Gormans Creek, Gormire Lake, Gormley Creek, Gornupkagama Lake, Gorrie Lake, Gorr Lakes, Gorse Creek, Gorse Lake, Gort Creek, Gort Lake, Goshawk Lake, Goshen Lake, Gosling Lake, Goldie Lake, Goldie River, Goldilocks Lake, Golding Lake, Gold Lake, Gold Mountain Lake, Goldsborough Creek, Goldsborough Lake, Gold Seekers Bay, Goldsmith Lake, Goldspink Lake, Goldstein Lake, Goldthrope Lake, Goldwin Creek, Goldwin Lake, Golf Course Bay, Golf Lake, Goltz Lake, Golub Lake, Gong Creek, Gong Lake, Gooch Creek, Gooch Lake, Goodchild Creek, Goodchild Lake, Goode Lake, Goodens Creek, Gooderham Creek, Gooderham Lake, Goodeve Lake, Goodfish Lake, Good Fortune Lake, Good Harbour, Goodie Creek, Goodie Lake, Goodier Lake, Goodkey Creek and Goodlad Lake.
  • The minister must direct the investigation; the bill does not create a new agency or specify who would carry it out.
  • The bill says it would come into force on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Residents and users of the listed waterways: The bill requires an investigation, but does not require publication of its findings or specify any later action.
  • People and businesses generally: The bill does not impose a new fee, ban, reporting duty or other direct requirement on them.
  • Taxpayers: The bill requires government work, but does not say what staff, resources or budget would be used.

Money#

The bill requires an investigation, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • It does not set out an appropriation, funding source, staffing level or expected cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a deadline, method or scope for the investigation beyond the listed waterways and the stated aim of determining the extent of the problem.
  • It does not say whether, when or how results would be made public.
  • It does not specify what action, if any, would follow the investigation.
  • The bill refers to subsection 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act, but that Act was not supplied, so its current requirements and how this bill relates to them could not be verified.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would require an investigation of the named waterways rather than leave that work to ministerial choice.
  • Collecting information about the listed waters could help establish the extent of the zebra mussel problem there. That is a possible benefit, not a result the bill guarantees.
  • Using the minister’s existing role under the Ontario Water Resources Act avoids creating a separate organization for the investigation.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set a deadline, method or reporting requirement, so it is unclear how complete or useful the investigation would be.
  • It requires an investigation but does not specify its cost or provide funding.
  • The bill does not require any response to the findings, so identifying a problem would not itself ensure further action.
  • The bill does not explain why these waterways were selected or how the investigation would relate to any existing work.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2018080802

    Passed50 members voted

    On motion by Mr. Bisson, Bill 21, An Act to require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to discharge the responsibilities under subsection 15 (1) of the Ontario…

    FOR · 48AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    48For

    • PC30
    • NDP17
    • Liberal1

    2Against

    • PC2