Summary#
Bill 183, the Strengthening Human Rights in Ontario Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Human Rights Code. It would require the Ontario Human Rights Commission to carry out its functions independently and consistently with named United Nations principles, and make most of a 2019 memorandum of understanding part of the Code. The stated goal is to strengthen the Commission’s independence.
- The Commission would have to follow the memorandum of understanding, except for its section on duration, review and amendment.
- The Attorney General would also have to follow the memorandum’s requirements.
- If the Commission failed to comply, that failure alone would not invalidate its actions or give anyone rights or remedies.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. It does not create a new organization.
What it means for you#
- Ontario Human Rights Commission: Its functions would have to be carried out independently and consistently with the named UN principles. It would also have to comply with the incorporated parts of the memorandum.
- Attorney General: The Attorney General would have to comply with the memorandum’s requirements.
- People who use or rely on the Commission: The bill does not directly change individual human rights protections or set out a new complaint or review process. It also says the Commission’s failure to follow the memorandum does not itself give anyone rights or remedies.
- General public: The bill does not say that the Commission’s functions or services would expand.
Money#
No publicly available information on costs is in the available material.
- The bill requires the Commission and Attorney General to comply with the memorandum, but gives no staffing or spending estimate.
What is unclear#
- The memorandum is not included in the supplied material, so its specific requirements cannot be described or checked.
- The bill does not explain what practical standards follow from the named UN principles.
- The memorandum’s section on duration, review and amendment is excluded from the Code, but the bill does not explain how the memorandum could otherwise be changed.
- The current Human Rights Code was not supplied, so its full existing provisions and how this bill would interact with them could not be verified.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to protect the Commission’s independence by making that a legal requirement for carrying out its functions.
- Making the memorandum part of the Code could give the Commission and Attorney General clearer, legally stated obligations.
- Requiring the Attorney General to comply as well as the Commission could help set boundaries for both sides of their relationship.
Case against#
- The bill does not include the memorandum’s text, making it hard to judge the obligations being added to the Code.
- A Commission failure to comply would not invalidate its actions or give anyone rights or remedies. That may limit the practical consequences of non-compliance.
- The bill does not set out a process for monitoring compliance or resolving disputes about whether the memorandum has been followed.