Bill Would Create Temporary Tribunal Panels

Summary#

Bill 226, the Fixing Tribunals Ontario Backlogs Act, 2024, would amend the Adjudicative Tribunals Accountability, Governance and Appointments Act, 2009, the Human Rights Code and the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. Its stated goal is to change tribunal appointments, advise on access to justice and create temporary panels to decide selected cases at two tribunals.

  • The Public Appointments Secretariat would have to publish and update weekly a list of tribunal appointees and intended appointees, with specified appointment details.
  • Tribunal appointments would have to use a competitive, merit-based process. A tribunal’s chair would have to approve each appointment or reappointment after assessing qualifications and, for reappointments, the member’s performance.
  • The Attorney General would have to establish an advisory Access to Justice Panel. It would make recommendations, not implement them.
  • The Minister would have to establish a temporary panel of adjudicators for the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario; the Attorney General would have to establish one for the Landlord and Tenant Board. The Standing Committee on Government Agencies would appoint their members and set criteria for selecting cases.
  • Each backlog panel would end once its assigned cases were resolved. The bill does not change the underlying rules for human rights claims or landlord-tenant disputes.

What it means for you#

  • People with cases at the Human Rights Tribunal or Landlord and Tenant Board: Some cases could be decided by a temporary panel, depending on criteria set by the Standing Committee. The bill does not specify which cases would be selected or change the rights or remedies in those cases.
  • Tribunal appointees and candidates: Recruitment steps and qualifications would have to be made public. The chair’s approval would be required for appointments and reappointments. Current members would remain until their terms end.
  • People seeking information about appointments: A public list would include names, positions, brief biographies and appointment terms. If an intended appointee was asked to appear before the committee, the list would also say when they appeared—or whether they gave a written explanation for not appearing.
  • People who use tribunals: The Access to Justice Panel must consider recommendations about tribunal independence, hearing access, and legal services. The bill does not itself provide new legal services or guarantee in-person or virtual hearings.
  • The public: The bill creates panels within the tribunal system, not new independent agencies. It does not create an independent Adjudicative Tribunal Justice Council; the advisory panel may recommend options for one.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires three panels to be established, but does not state their staffing or operating costs.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set remuneration and expenses for panel members, but only if the Legislature appropriates money for that purpose.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current versions of the amended Acts, so existing appointment rules, tribunal processes and backlog levels could not be checked against current law.
  • The bill does not set the case-selection criteria for either backlog panel or explain how individual cases would be referred to it.
  • It does not set rules for panel hearings, timelines, appeals or reporting on the Landlord and Tenant Board panel’s work.
  • The Access to Justice Panel makes recommendations; the bill does not require the government to adopt them.
  • The supplied text has inconsistent Act names: its explanatory note refers to the appointments Act as a 2019 Act, the operative text says 2009, and a transition provision refers to the Improving Access to Justice Act, 2024. The correct references should be checked against the official bill text.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address delays by adding temporary adjudicators to decide cases selected for the two backlog panels.
  • A merit-based process, public recruitment information and chair approval could make tribunal appointments more transparent and tie them to relevant qualifications.
  • A panel tasked with studying independence, hearing access and legal services could identify broader ways to improve access to justice.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Standing Committee a central role in appointing panel members and setting case-selection criteria, but does not explain how those decisions would be made.
  • It does not specify panel resources, decision timelines or detailed procedures, so the effect on backlogs is uncertain.
  • Chair approval adds a new step to appointments and reappointments; the bill does not explain how disagreements or delays would be handled.
  • The advisory panel may recommend changes, but the government is not required to implement them.